iMovie autosave is a bad idea

I'm curious. Who decided that having autosave turned on by default in iMovie is a good idea? It isn't. It's a very bad idea.

With autosave turned on by default, users can't explore editing ideas before choosing something that best serves their vision for a project. I lost hours of my life today because of iMovie autosave. I'll never get them back. They're gone forever and my project is in tatters.

Hey Apple! Please stop "helping" me. It's my project, not yours. Please allow users to decide when to save their projects.

iMac (2017 – 2020)

Posted on Mar 15, 2023 12:41 PM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Mar 15, 2023 2:40 PM

You may have a misunderstanding of what autosave does. All during the editing process iMovie periodically and automatically saves your project to the iMovie Backups folder located at this file path:


Go/Home/Library/Containers/com.apple.iMovieApp/Data/Library/Caches/iMovieBackups


During the editing process you can continue to make as many edits and changes that you want, and the project will be saved with the most current edits as you go along. That way, if you should happen to accidentally delete or lose your project you can retrieve it intact from the iMovie Backups folder. Good idea . . .or not?


If you want to explore different editing ideas before choosing a set of edits to export, that is done by making duplicates of the project. So, you do a combination of edits in the original project. Then make a duplicate of the original project. Working with the duplicate, you can do a completely different set of edits while the edits in the original project are preserved. You can create as many duplicates as you want, changing the edits as you wish,, and then choose the original project or any one or move of the duplicates to export out as the final project.


To duplicate a project, go to your project browser screen, where your projects are displayed as icons. Move your cursor over a project's icon and that will cause a little circle with dots in it to appear to the right of the title. Click on the circle to reveal a drop down menu. Choose Duplicate Project from the menu.



After doing that, a duplicate project will be created and displayed in the project browser, while the original project

is preserved.


-- Rich





2 replies
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Mar 15, 2023 2:40 PM in response to Art101_Design

You may have a misunderstanding of what autosave does. All during the editing process iMovie periodically and automatically saves your project to the iMovie Backups folder located at this file path:


Go/Home/Library/Containers/com.apple.iMovieApp/Data/Library/Caches/iMovieBackups


During the editing process you can continue to make as many edits and changes that you want, and the project will be saved with the most current edits as you go along. That way, if you should happen to accidentally delete or lose your project you can retrieve it intact from the iMovie Backups folder. Good idea . . .or not?


If you want to explore different editing ideas before choosing a set of edits to export, that is done by making duplicates of the project. So, you do a combination of edits in the original project. Then make a duplicate of the original project. Working with the duplicate, you can do a completely different set of edits while the edits in the original project are preserved. You can create as many duplicates as you want, changing the edits as you wish,, and then choose the original project or any one or move of the duplicates to export out as the final project.


To duplicate a project, go to your project browser screen, where your projects are displayed as icons. Move your cursor over a project's icon and that will cause a little circle with dots in it to appear to the right of the title. Click on the circle to reveal a drop down menu. Choose Duplicate Project from the menu.



After doing that, a duplicate project will be created and displayed in the project browser, while the original project

is preserved.


-- Rich





This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

iMovie autosave is a bad idea

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.