iMac failed to re-boot after using disk first aid - then failed to load backup from external disc backup

Using my late 2013 iMac in OS 10.13.6 High Sierra I was advised to use disc first aid as a routine check - even though the computer was functioning adequately. I had not previously used disc first aid in the eight years of using this iMac. Disc first aid informed me there was minor corruption on the hard disc and then repaired that successfully. It then informed me to turn the iMac off & then turn power back on & re-boot to open my desktop. 




Instead of the iMac re-booting from the existing High Sierra OS already within the iMac it posted a message saying it could not recognise the Apple server where it had intended getting a new version of High Sierra.




I now had a computer with no operating system & therefore it could not produce my desktop as it was permamnetly stuck with a blank black screen with just the Apple logo and a progress bar completed but frozen. Even after leaving it for at least eight hours overnight nothing changed.




Apple support told me to take it to an Apple store for them to sort it out. I did & the Apple store loaded OS 10.13.6 High Sierra back onto my computer but told me when they did that they discovered there was no information at all on the computer except that new OS High Sierra.




Although I was concerned about this bizarre turn of events I expected to be able to retrieve all my information as I always kept daily back ups using time machine and an external hard disc.




When I then used the Apple migration assistant to migrate the backup from my external backup hardisc but it uploaded a very  old backup that was useless. It then did the same with a second backup disc I had. It then became clear the iMac was not correctly reading either of the two external backup discs. I have spent the entire five days since this disaster commenced on Saturday November 11th until Thursday November 17th on the phone to numerous Apple support people who had given conflicting, inadequate & useless information. 




A vast amount of time was spent by them telling me High Sierra was obsolete & therefore  I should expect problems like this and that Apple support was unable to help me as I was at fault for failing to constantly 

upgrade my OS. I was  also told that my eight year old late 2013 iMac was also 'obsolete' and that Apple expected it to be un-usable as that computer hardware was also 'obsolete' the same as the OS High Sierra.




I am completely incredulous at what has happened and have been on the phone for many, many hours & told by Apple Support that nothing can be done to discover what is wrong, how it happend & why, and also why my two external backup discs cannot be read properly by the computer which then means I cannot retrieve my latest backup.




Does anyone else recorgnise this problem and know how to go about solving it as the loss of all my information has just about destroyed my life, preventring me working or doing anything at all.




The shambles I experienced from Apple support has already incurred huge phone bills and a large expense paying a fee to an Apple store to do absolutely nothing useful at all except installing an OS but losing all my data.




And a persistent thread of advice from these Apple support people has been their specific instruction to me that any purchase of any brand new computer only has a life of about seven years before becoming 'obsolete' and unsafe/potentially useless to use. I was also consistently told any computer or back-up of data cannot be relied on to function and all data can be permanently lost at any time.


Can any one suggest what I might be able to do about this ?









Posted on Nov 16, 2023 4:57 PM

Reply

Similar questions

1 reply

Nov 16, 2023 11:06 PM in response to Ziggyzig1

I have to ask... what prompted you to run Disk First Aid at the start of all of this trouble?

I assume you were experiencing some issue with the Mac, and I wonder if that may have been a sign of a failing hard drive.


A ten year old computer can experience a drive failure at any time, and that could well explain why First Aid found data corruption to begin with. And though it reported the corruption repaired, that may not have been accurate because First Aid routines are fairly limited in what they can repair.


A failing drive could also explain why you could not reboot the computer again normally after using Disk Utility.


Obviously the computer has failed, and now you have to decide what to do about it. This old iMac was bound to fail sooner or later, and ten years is a pretty good run for any computer. I think it's time to replace it.


Put your Time Machine backups aside for now until you get another working Mac. It's possible the data on those drives is still intact but the failed iMac just cannot access them properly.


I assume money is tight, so if you aren't looking to spend what a new computer will cost, I suggest you look at Apple's Certified Refurbished Macs here. These computers will come with a full warranty.


You might also give thought to a quality pre-owned Mac from macsales.com. These folks are a respected Mac and accessories vendor.


I'm sorry that you've had this unfortunate experience. If you're going to use computers, then sooner or later something like this going to happen. And it never happens at a good time. But you've done well to keep backups of your data, and with luck you can still recover your files. 🍀

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

iMac failed to re-boot after using disk first aid - then failed to load backup from external disc backup

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.