How do you save computation cycles by NOT EXPORTING/SHARING audio on iMovie

It's a little stupid that you can select "Video & Audio", or "Audio only" on the share/export window of iMovie, but there is no 'Video only', for this. Sure I know how to remove or disable the audio in the timeline, but in my tests I highly suspect that regardless, iMovie takes up compute cycles to render an audio file anyway, because the time it takes to render the same export files are similar, with and without the audio present or unchecked. I see on say, Handbrake, where when you deselect audio, the file size and time drops considerably. Should there not be a TRUE option to tell iMovie, 'don't waste time and energy computing the audio stream because I don't want it'? Am I wrong?


For clarity, I'm on Ventura (13.6.4) and using iMovie 10.4, on an iMac 19,1, but I know this to be true of every rendition of iMovie since it's inception because, yes, I'm that old (experienced). Anyone?

iMac 21.5″

Posted on Feb 2, 2024 8:52 AM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Feb 13, 2024 8:48 AM

Whether or not iMovie "should" have an option to export "video only" is a matter of desire or opinion. The fact is that it does not have that feature. You are free to submit your suggestion directly to Apple -> Product Feedback - Apple


Like Ian, however, I do not see this as a significant means to "save computation cycles." Audio represents only a small (some would say trivial) portion of the total data contained in a video file and the vast majority of the export/rendering time is consumed by handling the video. The small difference in file size and export time with/without audio is a reflection of that reality - you saw that yourself. If you have empirical data proving otherwise, we'd like to see it.


If you really need this option, then Final Cut would be the way to go.


Similar questions

6 replies

Feb 3, 2024 11:04 AM in response to Ian R. Brown

First off, 1% - should that be the case - which it is not - is a number above 0, and therefore not negligible. How you come to 1% is an entirely different question as my tests provide for it to be much more considerable than that. Compressor and Handbrake will indicate instantly that you can rise from - in my Experience - exporting from approximately 120 fps to 200+ fps, by simply turning off audio.


I am looking for an answer, not an opinion.

Feb 4, 2024 1:34 AM in response to jneedee2000

OK I will give you an answer.


iMovie is a free and comparatively simple editing app which provides all basic requirements.


It does not cover every eventuality and need especially ones which only one person in a million may require.


For editors who need more, there are professional apps like Final Cut Pro.


You may as well complain that your cheap car doesn't perform as well as a Rolls Royce. It's the same principle, you get what you pay (or don't pay) for.

Feb 4, 2024 2:25 AM in response to jneedee2000

Sorry, I did not answer the question of how I arrived at a figure of below 1%.


Here is the method which you can use yourself if you download the free app MediaInfo which measures the specifications of video clips.


I inserted a typical 1080p iMovie export and got the following results, the 2 relevant figures being the Video and Audio bit rates.


The Video bit rate is 20.0 Mb/s whilst the Audio bit rate is a minute 128 kb/s.


A simple calculation shows that the video is approximately 160 times bigger than the audio which equates to well under 1%



If you are really desperate to export Video Only you need a pro app like Final Cut Pro.


You can see in my screenshot that you have more control over your export options but I reiterate, you are worrying about something that will make no noticeable difference.


Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Feb 13, 2024 8:48 AM in response to jneedee2000

Whether or not iMovie "should" have an option to export "video only" is a matter of desire or opinion. The fact is that it does not have that feature. You are free to submit your suggestion directly to Apple -> Product Feedback - Apple


Like Ian, however, I do not see this as a significant means to "save computation cycles." Audio represents only a small (some would say trivial) portion of the total data contained in a video file and the vast majority of the export/rendering time is consumed by handling the video. The small difference in file size and export time with/without audio is a reflection of that reality - you saw that yourself. If you have empirical data proving otherwise, we'd like to see it.


If you really need this option, then Final Cut would be the way to go.


This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

How do you save computation cycles by NOT EXPORTING/SHARING audio on iMovie

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.