fcpx 10.9 timeline video corruption / distortion

I edit since 2015. Fcpx 10.1.4/ Mavericks 10.9.5, 1Tb internal HDD used 200Gb.

iMac 24G RAM/2G VRAM, 8Tb ext HDD (4T free), small project 300Gb,

Source files: GoPro Mp4, mixed with AVCHD Mp4 files, and bunch of older formats converted long ago to MP4 and used many times in various projects. All used to work well.


Everything was going fine until I used retime editor > FAST > 8x, 10x, 20x on over 20 clips imported just fine to the timeline (synchro with soundtrack beat). Then I added speed ramping in and out on two clips. Everything worked fine. I went to catch some sleep leaving project on standby (HDD off after 1 hr this worked many times before).

In the morning iMac was frozen, and after restart nothing worked properly any more.

Source files in browser show just fine, but timeline shows jumpy clips with out of sequence 1 frame glitches overwritten inside timeline clips (they are not so in source files). This is transferred to the exported range as well. Relinking source files does not help. Copy-paste into a new timeline carries over the glitches, and new ones appear in other clips of the timeline. Moving project to another, new Library does not help, so it is not a RAM glitch. Restarting FCPX does not help, Dumping prefs. during fcpx restart does not help.

Starting a new library and project, importing once again source data, inserting to a new timeline keeps resulting in the same glitches (quite many - shaky parts of the video in timeline (not in browser). I also imported quite DIFFERENT clips never used in this project - they show fine in fcpx browser, but do have some shaking here and there in timeline. This shaking increases when I try to move existing timeline structure, change cuts, move clips, stretch them etc. Any activity makes shaking/jumping worse.


Next I am to restart iMac with flashing RAM (power cable out for 30sec.)

It all seems to point to FCPX corruption... correct?

If so where can I find a dmg of this version of registered fcpx?

I looked for help at fcp.co but they closed this large forum there, that helped many for so many years...

Any ideas?

Thanks!

Posted on Feb 25, 2024 4:29 PM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Feb 27, 2024 8:25 PM

I did power down the whole system, unplugged power for over an hour. Then powered back. I moved the project to a new library. I moved it to another HDD (external). The error (juggy picture in timeline and export) was still there.

I do have 75% of system drive free.


I created another new library on the editing drive (the same where the error first occurred). I imported the same source files from another footage drive. This time I re-created beginning of the same film anew. All works fine.

It seems that the problem must have happened only in one library, and I cannot copy anything from that timeline to save myself time. The whole film was almost ready and it took many hours to get that project there. Well, I never before encountered anything like this hence my question to others. The only non standard function I was doing here was playing with a larger number of timelapse footages (over 20 clips) where I was re-adjusting their speed to synchro it with beat of soudtrack. There was on or two timeramps there (in and out) with the same time speed adjustment to fit all the footage into beat. Beyond that nothing amazing, no SF/x, no generators, just bunch of titles (4-5) for scenes. All source files in Mp4 (GoPro and AVCHD from XA10 and a pocket AVCHD H264 AAC, and few MP4 clips from a Galaxy A71, so there should not be any footage format issues).


There was no missing files, nor any other issues that I would know about. I only had to restart FCPX with trashing prefs for speed, as it got slow working days on this one project. But there was no issues while closing or opening program or project.


Still puzzled... as when I transfered data from "misbehaving" library to a new library they came even more distorted than in the first place. It seamed like each time I touched the original timeline to do any adjustment, the new glitches were appearing, and the only way out was to undo any changes to the timeline.


What comes to me is that it must have been something I did to the timeline what came through unnoticed that started this "corruption" process... and it had to do with the timing itself (time synchro?) I think, as the more I was doing of any further adjustments (cut, move, retime) it started affecting the whole project. So perhaps if I undo as many changes as possible (not sure how many steps I have FCPX set up to) I could get the whole thing to "fix itself"... But the main question remains...

Is it known to the community if there are any known reasons/situations that could cause this type of the distortion? As I mentioned it seems like my editing (first time I used so much of retiming of the timelapse footage) might have caused it. I just want to learn what to watch for...


I shall try all the received suggestions and will post the results...

As of now I know that this distortion has been written into the project file, as it carried over to the other drive in a new copy of the library, as well as with the data when I copied the project to a new library, but it was not showing in the clip browser of the new library where the "fresh" source files were imported again.


I wish there was a way to peak into the code of what FCPX wrote into the list of instructions. This would help to find the offending code (debugging), but first I shall post what I found after undoing what I could.


Thank you a lot for sharing your thoughts, it gave me some ideas too!

Similar questions

7 replies
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Feb 27, 2024 8:25 PM in response to terryb

I did power down the whole system, unplugged power for over an hour. Then powered back. I moved the project to a new library. I moved it to another HDD (external). The error (juggy picture in timeline and export) was still there.

I do have 75% of system drive free.


I created another new library on the editing drive (the same where the error first occurred). I imported the same source files from another footage drive. This time I re-created beginning of the same film anew. All works fine.

It seems that the problem must have happened only in one library, and I cannot copy anything from that timeline to save myself time. The whole film was almost ready and it took many hours to get that project there. Well, I never before encountered anything like this hence my question to others. The only non standard function I was doing here was playing with a larger number of timelapse footages (over 20 clips) where I was re-adjusting their speed to synchro it with beat of soudtrack. There was on or two timeramps there (in and out) with the same time speed adjustment to fit all the footage into beat. Beyond that nothing amazing, no SF/x, no generators, just bunch of titles (4-5) for scenes. All source files in Mp4 (GoPro and AVCHD from XA10 and a pocket AVCHD H264 AAC, and few MP4 clips from a Galaxy A71, so there should not be any footage format issues).


There was no missing files, nor any other issues that I would know about. I only had to restart FCPX with trashing prefs for speed, as it got slow working days on this one project. But there was no issues while closing or opening program or project.


Still puzzled... as when I transfered data from "misbehaving" library to a new library they came even more distorted than in the first place. It seamed like each time I touched the original timeline to do any adjustment, the new glitches were appearing, and the only way out was to undo any changes to the timeline.


What comes to me is that it must have been something I did to the timeline what came through unnoticed that started this "corruption" process... and it had to do with the timing itself (time synchro?) I think, as the more I was doing of any further adjustments (cut, move, retime) it started affecting the whole project. So perhaps if I undo as many changes as possible (not sure how many steps I have FCPX set up to) I could get the whole thing to "fix itself"... But the main question remains...

Is it known to the community if there are any known reasons/situations that could cause this type of the distortion? As I mentioned it seems like my editing (first time I used so much of retiming of the timelapse footage) might have caused it. I just want to learn what to watch for...


I shall try all the received suggestions and will post the results...

As of now I know that this distortion has been written into the project file, as it carried over to the other drive in a new copy of the library, as well as with the data when I copied the project to a new library, but it was not showing in the clip browser of the new library where the "fresh" source files were imported again.


I wish there was a way to peak into the code of what FCPX wrote into the list of instructions. This would help to find the offending code (debugging), but first I shall post what I found after undoing what I could.


Thank you a lot for sharing your thoughts, it gave me some ideas too!

Feb 27, 2024 11:26 PM in response to terryb

Thank you for your tip. I never really thought about working on my system drive, but I tried moving copy of the project files to a new library, and it did not help, the error transferred with it, So I tried first the tip from Ben (how could I forget about it... I just never had to do so I guess). I deleted rendered files and after rendering rebuilt the problem was gone and my work saved. Thank you for your suggestion.

Feb 27, 2024 8:34 PM in response to BenB

Thank you :-D

I have around 70% free of the system HDD, I use only external drives. I edit on RAID (2 HDD) for speed, and all the source clips are on a different HDD as well as sound libraries, and SF/x are on another one. This way I keep drives fast and organized.


Deleting FCPX prefs did not help so it must have been saved in what I have done I think. I was forcing re-rendering (no change), but have not removed rendered files yet... thanks. (I should have done so... how did I miss it?! Thanks). I shall report back outcome of this.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

fcpx 10.9 timeline video corruption / distortion

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.