Unable to fully sign in to Apple ID on new Macbook Air

I have a new MacBook Air 2024 M3. Every time I try to sign via the System Settings > Sign In, it resets. I enter my apple ID username and hit enter, then it asks for my password which I enter, then it spins for a moment and resets to asking for my apple ID username again.

Interestingly, when I go to appleid.apple.com, it shows this macbook air as a device connected to my apple ID. When I "forget device" through appleid.apple.com and try the same method of signing in, it still won't sign in on the computer but shows up again as a device logged in under my list of devices.

When I try to add an iCloud account under System Settings > Internet Accounts, the same thing happens. I click iCloud, plug in my info, and then it resets to asking me which type of account I'm logging in to.