You can make a difference in the Apple Support Community!
When you sign up with your Apple Account, you can provide valuable feedback to other community members by upvoting helpful replies and User Tips.
When you sign up with your Apple Account, you can provide valuable feedback to other community members by upvoting helpful replies and User Tips.
One of the folders is seen in iCloud Drive, the other books folder is not visible
This is very confusing. I would like to see all books in one folder, not two. And not with the same name.
Duplicates arise easily in Books app, and this is a problem too.
MacBook Air (M3, 2024)
Not having them in one location makes it impossible to discover duplicates or books that do not show up in the Books App.
Books app is not designed to work that way. You interact with your books via the app. Just like with Photos, Contacts, and a whole host of other apps on your Mac. If you are losing annotations I suggest you troubleshoot that, as the apparent duplication is not the likely cause, but rather a failure in the books database. I do not believe the annotations are stored "in" the book, but rather in that DB.
Then don't compare it to Music app, compare it to Contacts, where you can't see where the library is.
But this doesn't matter. How you think things should be is interesting biographical information, but that is not how Books.app works. The developers have designed it in the way they have. Your options are simple: use the App as it is designed to be used or use an app that works the way you prefer. Using the app is not compulsory and there are other options. What's not an option is to alter how the app works.
Oh and you can transfer books to a new computer via iCloud, quite seamlessly.
Calibre is an excellent open-source manager for a library of books - I have some 4k books in two libraries managed by it. If you want an app that syncs across devices then check out Yomu, it's inexpensive. And there are more options than that again.
Bomiboll wrote:
One of the folders is seen in iCloud Drive, the other books folder is not visible
This is very confusing. I would like to see all books in one folder, not two. And not with the same name.
Duplicates arise easily in Books app, and this is a problem too.
See if there is anything here
ref:Apple Books User Guide for Mac - Apple Support
If you want to see your books in one location you look at the books app. What goes on behind the scenes is not of relevance - there are no user-serviceable parts there.
Yomu is a very poor reading experience. I would not use that.
Calibre has no collections like Books has. That is a problem.
It shows where my library folder is, an information I wanted.
Here is an example of what Books app shows, telling that it has found duplicates
I wonder what it means "modifications aren't in sync" duplicates appear here and there
Not having them in one location makes it impossible to discover duplicates or books that do not show up in the Books App.
Searching for a book with spotlight refers to the folder location. Then I open that book and make annotations. Next time I open that book, the annotations are gone. That is because there are duplicates or triplicates
If you compare to Music app, i can see where the library is.
So I can search it for duplicates, if there are any. For this task I can use an app like Speedy Duplicate Finder or Gemini or even manually check it. But as for the Books app there is no option like that.
I always want to know where an app keeps its library (i e my files); it makes transfer to another computer much safer. If you don't know where your files are , you may lose them
Yomu is a very poor reading experience. I would not use that.
Then use something else. Whatever. It doesn't change the fact that you can't change how Books.app works.
Calibre has no collections like Books has. That is a problem.
You can easily create collections in Calibre using Tags. Or use something else. Whatever. It doesn't change the fact that you can't change how Books.app works.
Books app keeps books in two folders with the name "books"
