What is the best VPN?

Can anyone provide a recommended VPN? I was looking at PCMags list of Best VPNs for iPhones for 2025 and was wondering if anyone had direct experience?



[Edited by Moderator]

Posted on Feb 22, 2025 9:58 AM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Feb 22, 2025 10:48 AM

Proton VPN claims they do not log, but that isn't true (surprised?). All you need to do is look around with a search for "does Proton VPN log data". And yes, they do.


Partly, they can't help logging at least your real IP address since you would otherwise not be able to login to your account. A user noted in one topic I found that when they used a Tor browser, their account was immediately deleted. So, if Proton VPN isn't logging data, how would they know the user was using Tor? I suppose the IP addresses of the sites they were connecting would give that away, but you still need logs to find and track that information.


VPNs cost money to run. Hardware, electricity, staff to maintain and run them. For the very few who don't log data (they occasionally get audited to confirm no logs), they have to pay for those expenses somehow. Then it's unwanted ads being pushed to your browser. Or selling the email addresses of their users to spammers and marketers. Whatever they do to cover those costs, you're paying for it somehow. And the best part is, they're not telling you that.


Unless they person running the VPN is rich and is generously doing it as a truly free service because, well, they're just so darn nice, then they are making money to pay for everything one way or another. Logging data is the most common way as it's the best and easiest source to sell as marketing data.


As far as security, VPNs are not security software. Period. They don't block you from visiting suspect sites. They don't stop anything from being download to your computer no matter how dangerous it may be. They don't hide your data since everything out of the VPN to whatever site you're visiting and back to the VPN is in the clear.


What if that "free" VPN is located in China or Russia? Do you really want your communications with your bank going through them?


Did you read this link?


Free VPNs sell your data (just one of many sites explaining this)


And that's from 2022. There is gobs of information out there on this issue.


Or how about this one? VPN reviews you find online are also almost completely untrustworthy:


Former Malware Distributor Kape Technologies Now Owns ExpressVPN, CyberGhost, Private Internet Access, Zenmate, and a Collection of VPN “Review” Websites


The closest you can come to calling VPNs security software is they may - briefly - hide your true location. That can be important to a journalist in a violent regime who put people trying to report the truth away, never to be seen again.


General VPNs are also somewhat quickly becoming obsolete. Service providers are very much pushing all users to make their sites secure (httpS). Like here, as noted by the lock icon in Safari by the URL. Since the communication between yourself and the site is already encrypted, what is the VPN adding? The answer is nothing. You don't need it.

30 replies

Feb 22, 2025 11:15 AM in response to TonyTheGeek

Here’s a real world issue with VPN’s. Banks are refusing to added credit and debit cards to Apple Wallet and Google Pay if a VPN is on the iPhone. Just turning it off will not suffice for some banks. Once the VPN is detected the card may be blocked from adding for 30+ days.


This type of backlash against VPN’s is being more popular, from I’m learning. I recently attended a security webinar/online conference that discussed VPN usage. It sounded as though several industries are looking at security measures to block VPN’s.



Feb 22, 2025 11:23 AM in response to TonyTheGeek

That's a circle of nonsense if there ever was one.

And, btw, HTTPS encrypted traffic remains encrypted traffic through the VPN. You do not give up any security in that regard and no the VPN provider can't see it.

Thank you for explaining the bluntly obvious. All without mentioning an httpS connection makes the entire concept of a VPN completely pointless. Yup, encrypting the encrypted data. Soooo useful.

What it does do is obscure your IP and ergot physical location from the owner of the HTTPS site, whomever that happens to be.

And why would I care about that? I don't deal with shady vendors. I don't use P2P, file sharing or pirate sites.

Do you think all the sites on the internet are run by well intentioned angels unlike the villainous VPN providers?

Now you're really reaching. You can be taken advantage by anyone, anywhere. Like the skanky auto shop that charges you for work they didn't do. Or charging you for a much more expensive genuine part when they actually put in a cheap third party piece of junk. Crooks are everywhere, not just on the internet.

VPN absolutely provides security, just because it doesn't provide every type of security is irrelevant.

Um, sure. Right up until the data comes out the other side of the VPN to the site you're using. Then for all intents and purposes, the VPN doesn't exist.



There's no point continuing this discussion. You had your mind made up before you even asked a question. Which only leaves the question; why did you bother posting at all?

Feb 22, 2025 11:50 AM in response to TonyTheGeek

The real issue is every fraudster uses a VPN to hide their location. The ones implementing the technology now are the big banks. Fraud is hitting them the hardest because of the sheer number of account holders.


It’s not the sale of personal information. The banks get everything from the merchant either way. It’s the use of fraudulent cards and account information obtained fraudulently that cost big bank $$ billions.

Feb 22, 2025 11:52 AM in response to TonyTheGeek

I already understood and knew the purpose. I don't care if a trusted vendor knows my IP address.


We give away personal information every single day. Like when you use your credit cards. When you have your cell phone on (you're being tracked 24/7 whether you like it or not). When you fill in your personal address and phone number to just about every purchase you make online or in a store.


As noted all the way back in 1999, Scott McNealy famously said, “You have zero privacy anyway. Get over it."


Being careful is normal. Being neurotic about it is not.


And even that can't be a certainty. We ordered a wood puzzle for my mother-in-law as a birthday present through Amazon. Took a while to get it as it shipped to us directly from the vendor. Well, the puzzle was $29.99 and was billed as such along with the other items we purchased.


But as we went through our recent credit card bill the other day, right next to the Amazon order was another $44.99 purchase directly from the same company we got the puzzle from. Since Amazon had to relay our credit card information to the vendor to get the puzzle, then the only logical chain of events is someone at the puzzle company decided to buy a puzzle for themselves using our credit card info.


Had to have to charge reversed and the card cancelled/replaced. So what did we do wrong? Technically, nothing. The name of the vendor on Amazon isn't the name of the site it came from. But that's literally the only connection between the valid purchase and the fraudulent one. That, and puzzle we did order is right on their site. So we know that's where the fraud occurred.

Feb 22, 2025 12:44 PM in response to TonyTheGeek

That’s minuscule compared to the fraud. I don’t think you have an understanding of how Apple Pay works. Apple Pay transactions give the bank the same information the use of the card does. Apple Pay prevents the card information and account holders personal information from the merchant. The bank and networks (Visa, MasterCard etc.) get your card and transaction information either way. They lose billions from fraudulent charges. Apple Pay reduces merchant exposure due to employees, hackers etc.


VPN allows credit card information to be added to electronic wallets. The true location of the smartphone is hidden by the VPN when cards are added to e-wallets and online transactions are completed.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

What is the best VPN?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.