Tamlouie wrote:
I was bothered by the same type question of account.apple.com not recognizing my apple id password but instead it prompts for the laptop login password. I haven't found an answer for correcting this, or making the sign in stop asking for the laptop login, but I read thru the thread a few times and from what MrHuffman wrote copied below I was apple to choose to login in with apple id password. I wish the apple account only accepted the apple id password, but it's a work around I suppose.
You can use the Mac password to access the saved password in Keychain and use that,
or can override the password autofill and select the Apple Account and password directly in the input box.
if you want to enter your passwords everywhere, disable Apple Keychain; disable the built-in password manager.
By disabling it, you will have exactly what you expect here, a prompt for the Apple Account password.
But that also means you are much easier to phish; to enter your real Apple Account or other important password in some fake website or some pop-up somewhere or some real-looking text message.
Beyond making getting phished harder, using a password manager also means you can also easily use unique per-website passwords, and also use per-website passkeys, which completely avoids the catastrophe that commonly happens when important passwords are reused. You also get built-in warnings about any of your passwords that have been found compromised.
Yes, the password manager will prompt for an unlock, either with a password for the password manager — which is what this whole thread is about — or with a Face ID or Touch ID biometric unlock, depending on your Apple gear and your settings.
So decide what y’all want here. Traditional security that requires you to remember all of your passwords, that is much easier to phish, and that is prone to loss of all accounts if (when?) a password is reused, because remembering passwords and particularly unique passwords is an increasing problem for most of us.
This password reuse attacks mentioned are far from theoretical, too. This so-called password cramming happens a whole lot, and around here we too often get to see people lose their accounts, lose their data, and (if the original purchase receipts aren’t available*) permanently lose all their Apple devices permanently gone.
So pick your preferred configuration: with the password manager enabled (and this password manager password prompt), or without.
To shut off the built-in password manager in recent Safari versions on Mac, open Safari, select Settings, select Autofill (circled), un-select users and passwords (circled):

With the password manager disabled and autofill off, you’ll get exactly what you expect, unfortunately including the related problems that arise with the traditional direct password entry.
*such as purchase receipts stored in the iCloud files and photos and sata associated with the lost Apple Account