Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

iTunes Match Match Explicit Songs Matches Clean

I am having issues where some songs that have explicit words are being replaced by songs that have been censored ( clean version ). I am pretty particular about my music, ever time I hear a song that has been censored, it is like nails on a chalkboard to me.


Some of my songs are being properly matched, Eminem for instance seems to have no problem being matched, however Blink-182 gets matched with the clean version.


I hope Apple will correct this before this comes out of beta, for an Apple product I am thoroughly disappointed.


~Chris

Mac Pro, Mac OS X (10.7.2)

Posted on Nov 16, 2011 12:30 PM

Reply
146 replies

Mar 30, 2012 6:53 AM in response to housemr

For me it's censoring two Nas albums. It Was Written and "Nas" - which is the real atrocity given it's subject matter about censorship. Both albums were purchased via iTunes before they removed the DRM protection and they have "Explicit" meta tags. Then the Lil Wayne "Tha Carter IV" is also censored. Not an iTunes download, just a "match". I dunno, I'm back to syncing the old fashion way because listening to cleaned music is simply unacceptable to me, especially given I'm paying for the service.

Mar 30, 2012 7:02 AM in response to edditnyc

That untitled/self-titled Nas album is wrong for me, too.


I've gone back and forth in emails with support now, and they're just giving me the runaround. I'm getting more and more ****** by the day.


This is currently the only way I have to listen to my music collection in my apartment. I guess I'm gonna go back to Amazon cloud player or google music, because this is worthless.

Mar 30, 2012 7:24 AM in response to Spy_Hardman

Another issue I have with itunes match is I can't manually manage what's stored on my phone. It's all or nothing.

If i want to make sure something is stored locally I have to download over wifi before I leave home if I dont want to pull it up streaming.


Also I'm not completley sure how it works, it seems like it downloads the songs, but does it ever delete them? there should be a way to manage what you want to stream and what you want to store locally. This way if you download a explicit song you can delete it from you phone and re-download the explicit version (in the case that they ever fix this issue).


My subscription is half up and this thing seemed to roll out in a beta form and is till not 100% working.


I also had issues with my playlists updating. Seems to be working better with the latest updates, but still its difficult to manage playlists there are a bunch of dups that pull in different tracks from Recently Added. I have like 3 different Recently Added Smart playlists and they are not that smart.

Mar 30, 2012 11:09 AM in response to MjaMes1409

From my understanding, only Apple TV truly streams music from iTunes Match. The way it works for iPod & iPhones is it'll start streaing once you initate the download but it downloads the content to your phone so you can replay it later. If you want to remove it, you can swipe the Album in the Music app to remove it.


However this doesn't remove or correct what's already on the Cloud for iTunes Match if the album is clean or mismatched to a live album or something. You can only do that via a Mac or PC using iTunes at home by highlighting the album and pressing Delete. It offers you a checkbox to remove from the cloud and then after wards you have to say No to deleting it to the trash (just remove it from iTunes). However when I added the album back to rematch it, I haven't had success getting my 3 albums uncensored on the cloud.


It's not all bad and it's not all the albums that get mismatched. In practice it actually works great and I haven't had issues manually managing my music. Perhaps you just need to check the "Manage My Music" box in iTunes on your PC/Mac to set it up. I just hope the Match fix on Apple's end is on the way soon.

Mar 30, 2012 4:35 PM in response to FortressNZ

Sure, it's a bug and it needs to be fixed, but this is not an easy thing to fix. By matching songs based on title, artist, album, and length makes it pretty easy to match songs (I think that is how they do it, it's how lala did it and that's what iTunes Match is built on). To match edited and non edited music automatically would require some form of sound wave analysis on Apples part, which I can imagin is a much more complicated process, plus you have millions of tracks to perform this on to build the database on, which really complicates the entire process. It will get fixed, it will just take time.

Apr 5, 2012 7:58 PM in response to Christopher Golding

It really can be simpler than you think. In my case, all I need is an account option that says "Default to explicit versions when matching songs". My purchased songs work fine. My uploaded songs obviously work fine. When the sound wave analysis is complete, the iTunes servers should recognize that there are two files to choose from. Use a "default" account setting or provide a window to select on a song-by-song basis. Either way, it is better than the wholesale cleaning of my entire ripped library.

Apr 14, 2012 6:35 PM in response to Christopher Golding

I'm sure this was luck more than anything else, but iTunes Match gave me a censored version of Monster by Kanye West (off of My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy). It was awful. I deleted the file from my MBP and redownloaded from iCloud, though, and was just given an explicit recording. No idea what prompted the change but maybe you'll get lucky?

Apr 14, 2012 6:47 PM in response to annnthony

@ annnthony- I will certainly test your theory. That may help as I find songs that came in as "edited" from iTunes Match. But really I need Apple to get to the bottom of this. I can manage to fix a few this way, but I have literally hundreds of explicit songs that have (as far as I can tell) been affected by this. I get that early adopters get to deal with the bugs. I just want Apple to officially announce this issue and keep us informed of the progress.

iTunes Match Match Explicit Songs Matches Clean

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.