Hi Jim,
My lengthy response to your questions was done keeping in mind that others interested in vinyl might happen upon it. My own record collection, some 6,000 Lps, uncounted 45's and a handful of 78's, are probably as old as what you have and much of the collection could well be in worse condition than what you have, since I gather you purchased them new. I admit I've bought much more than I've had time to clean and listen to, let alone record. Most of my collection was purchased second-hand from various sources in the last 5 years, although there is that one box that back in the 70's got put in the back of the car every time I moved. Admittedly those albums are the worst of the lot!
Anyway, while I do evaluate every disc before purchase, not everything is mint by any means and ClickRepair does come in very handy for me. I've just come to understand how much I lose if I don't ride herd on the app. For me it is important to retain as much of the music as I can within reason of course, particularly because I found I can tell the difference between the record and digital if I just let ClickRepair have its way. I admit I also enjoy experimenting and trying to improve my recording process. We all need a hobby, right?
Besides, while I like to listen to the originals when I can, often it's not possible, or simply not convenient. Firing up the AppleTV while I work around the house works pretty well for me. I get a lot of satisfaction also out of knowing my wife, who is 10 years younger than I am, is coming to enjoy music she never heard before, thanks to the vinyl rips she's loading up on her iPod.
JIm