Yes, you can include me as another person who is very grateful to have found this thread and am adding my story to this thread hoping it might help someone out there. My story:
• After syncing my iPhone 6 with a 3rd party (Belkin) USB cable (that actually came as part of a car charger), my early 2011 MacBook Pro was dead!
• Took it to the Apple Store and after they did a trouble shoot on it (to no avail) told me that I needed to replace the motherboard and it would cost me $310 Dollars (the price they came up with is quite interesting after reading all of the posts here as I believe they base their repair price off of a certain percentage of what they think the computer is worth - basically a "sweet spot" that is just enough under the value of the re-sale value of the computer to make it tempting but enough so they can make some $ off of you - this is a whole other story / thread in the making...).
• I was glad that I decided I needed to sleep on it!
• When I got home that evening I tried again to see if I could start up and that is when I noticed the faint glow from the power cable. That prompted me to do a little searching online which is when, to my amazement, I found this thread that described the exact issue!
• It was actually not until I read through this thread that I recognized the cause of the issue - the 3rd party Belkin cable that I used for the sync just before the computer shut down.
• Upon waking the next day (24 hours from the meltdown), the computer was still unresponsive so I embarked on the "disconnecting the battery" fix.
• I needed to keep the battery unplugged from the motherboard for much longer than I expected - a few minutes - which I am guessing was because the capacitors needed to discharge or something to that effect. Anyhow, after a few minutes I tried the AC cable and she was back in action!
• Once I got the computer re-started my battery life was at 91% after 24 hours of sitting there. So I am guessing I would've been waiting for several more days if I was going to attempt the "let the battery drain" method.
• I did a p-ram re-boot first thing once it started up and the time / date was re-set from disconnecting the battery.
• No data lost and no ill effect from the USB short or the repair.
My frustration with Apple is that, even after spending my whole day waiting and then getting helped by a "qualified" technician at an Apple Store, they did not have the training or resource prowess to take some simple steps that would have solved the issue quickly:
1) Ask me what I am now humbly remembering as a golden first question to ask when trouble shooting ALL technology: "Did you do something different that you don't normally do when using "x" right before the problem appeared?" That question would have pointed directly to the 3rd party cable!
2) I am shocked by this whole experience in that it is obvious the Apple Store is NOT using any kind of online search options or support database to find out if such a problem already exists and what the solution might be. They went right for the "nuclear option" of, "You need a new motherboard". I have found that to be the case with the phone support too. When I have called to address Mac or iPhone issues it seems a little too quick that the solution is becoming, "You need to do an erase and install". Yes, easy for you to say - do you have an extra day or two of time I can borrow? 😀
The biggest learning for me from this is to FIRST (before I bring my computer ANYWHERE to get looked at) do my own much more extensive at home trouble shooting and online research.
Hope this helps Mac friends!
~ Antonio ~