@josephavellino: To be honest, it was easy and the process proved to be very interesting. I am based in LA and have a business account with Apple so there is a lot of inventory near by.
I like you have all versions of iPhone and iPads, MacBook Pro's, iMac’s, Apple TV and the list goes on. Point being that I too have been very passionate about the brand and their products since being introduced to them going all the back to the early 90’s.
Much like you, once I identified the camera problem, it seems almost not real that we would have not only a camera issue, but multiple issues with one of the most anticipated devices in the last 5 years.
I think that Apple is challenged in many ways right now, with Steve being gone topping the list. Beyond that however is the demand for inventory, product evolution, and quality control. It’s seems unthinkable to have to deliver 10mm units in a 4 week window and have them all be working as planned, especially with a $199.00 price tag to enter the iPhone 5 world.
I try and keep perspective by looking back 5 years and looking at all of the things that we can do remotely, never possible before or with any other device. I know that statement is subjective but we use our devices non-stop in the field of event production and what I get outside of the convenience of my camera is pretty unbelievable, with remote machine management, assets access and transfer, real-time reporting from the field and so many other things that once required a laptop. Bottom line, I have yet to be introduced to any device that even comes close to an Apple product for what I use it for. As to the Samsung Galaxy III, I think that its amusing that they call themselves a competitor. I feel like it’s just a different consumer.
Back to the matter at hand, I called the store at the Groove in LA [their flagship] and asked a business associate to check if they had a replacement device as mine is white 64gb. After checking my serial number, he checked and they did have a replacement in stock. I asked if it was b-stock and he said that it was new, but not in a box. To that end, they had none for sale but devices to swap out. I was told to setup a genius bar appointment, which they could make for me 2 days later. I did not feel like I needed to wait or argue about the situation, I just wanted a new device.
A day later, I checked with the Beverly Center store [as I just purchased 30 iPod touches for a project] and they too gave me the same info, none for sale but they had a replacement. I’m not going to speculate as its prohibited in the T & C’s but you can read between the lines. The big difference though is the replacement device did come fresh out of the box.
In conclusion, I don’t know if you will meet any resistance but based on your brand loyalty, it seems like they would take care of you.
Good luck and I hope this helps.