Apple Event: May 7th at 7 am PT

Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

iTunes 11 for Mac: Search is completely broken.

Argh!


So Apple - when you test iTunes - how many songs are you testing against?


My iTunes library has about 83k songs, 5,143 albums.


I loaded iTunes 11, and......


1.) Search is completely broken. As in, it DOES NOT WORK. Search should wait for typing to be completed or <enter> hit before trying to search. With a large iTunes library on a fairly new Mac, hit one letter - get spinny ball - wait 3 minutes - get result from first letter back. Wait to search for "The Grey Album" would potentially take a half hour of waiting. IT IS HORRIBLY BAD!


Without search - it's VERY difficult to navigate the collection of music I have,


PLEASE FIX THIS!


Thanks

Posted on Nov 29, 2012 11:59 AM

Reply
48 replies

Nov 29, 2012 2:42 PM in response to Genettic

Genettic wrote:


My impression of turning off "Search Entire Library" seems to be that it reverts back to iTunes 10's method of searching (only search in current playlist/view, show results in main panel instead of new fancy dropdown, etc.). So, not any worse off than we were yesterday, I suppose.


I'm in my Louis Armstrong playlist, which contains 1,211 tunes. I deselect Search Entire Library and search "angel." Every tune or album in the Louis Armstrong playlist with the word "angel" quickly appears, but no song from any other playlist. Staying in the same playlist, I reselect Search Entire Library, erase and reenter "angel." (If I don't erase it nothing changes. Bug.) Then iTunes arduously searches the entire library, finds, and displays, in a glitzy panel, a sample of everything that has "angel" in it, including albums, songs, movies, etc. Then I click on one choice -- say, songs -- and it shows a list with artwork icons and a plus to the left of the icon which I have to click if I want to be taken to the song file in the Songs view. It is the effort that goes into finding and displaying that showy list that bogs down iTunes. That is a far cry from the way prior versions of iTunes searched, and it takes much longer and more steps. It is, however, much, much prettier.


If you happen to stop at "a" rather than quickly typing "angel," you will wait for iTunes to locate every item that contains the letter "a," which takes a lot longer than 20 seconds, and there is no way to interrupt that search.

Nov 29, 2012 2:50 PM in response to macCesar

macCesar wrote:


Turning off 'Search Entire Library' is the only know solution for now until Apple fix it.


But the problem IS that iTunes 11 cannot do a 'live' search on a very large library.


I want to know how it is that some people are apparently, contrary to logic, searching their entire libraries with Search Entire Library deselected, when I can only search the playlist I'm within if I do the same thing. What are you doing that I am not?


If the option was Turn Off Live Search, I could understand, but it is doing for me exactly as I might expect. I turn off Search Entire Library and it will not search the entire library, live or not.


Someone please duplicate exactly what I described a couple of posts back -- searching from within a playlist with Search Entire Library off -- and report your result.

Nov 29, 2012 4:09 PM in response to drewbie-do-be-do

When I turn off "Seach Entire Library", but still have "Music" selected in the sidebar, iTunes does indeed search all the tracks in Music, but excludes all other categories (TV Shows, etc.). If I turn "Search Entire Library" back on, it searches all categories, and it's excruciatingly slow (30 seconds).


If I'm in a playlist with "Seach Entire Library" turned OFF, it searches just within that playlist, and it isn't exactly fast (~3-5 seconds).

If I'm in a playlist with "Seach Entire Library" turned ON, it searches the entire Library and it's excruciatingly slow (30 seconds.)


Library is 126,750 songs/1.740GB on an external drive. Spotlight has indexed the drive.


OS 10.7.5/24" iMac 3GHz Duo/8Gb RAM


Other than the slowdown and the little goofy pop-out list of results a la Spotlight, search seems to work the same as it did in the last version of iTunes.

Nov 29, 2012 5:01 PM in response to pixeljammer

pixeljammer wrote:


When I turn off "Seach Entire Library", but still have "Music" selected in the sidebar, iTunes does indeed search all the tracks in Music, but excludes all other categories (TV Shows, etc.). If I turn "Search Entire Library" back on, it searches all categories, and it's excruciatingly slow (30 seconds).


If I'm in a playlist with "Seach Entire Library" turned OFF, it searches just within that playlist, and it isn't exactly fast (~3-5 seconds).

If I'm in a playlist with "Seach Entire Library" turned ON, it searches the entire Library and it's excruciatingly slow (30 seconds.)


Library is 126,750 songs/1.740GB on an external drive. Spotlight has indexed the drive.


OS 10.7.5/24" iMac 3GHz Duo/8Gb RAM


Other than the slowdown and the little goofy pop-out list of results a la Spotlight, search seems to work the same as it did in the last version of iTunes.


You describe ways in which it is profoundly different and then say it works the same. You are right that with Songs selected it does search the entire collection, without the awesomely useless "pop-out list," even with Search Entire Library deselected. But it is still slower at that than searching used to be, and it requires some prep steps that weren't formerly needed. When I look at Songs view it also has a three panel window at the top, with Genres, Artists, and Albums, which is unnecessary clutter. Is there a way to get rid of that window?

iTunes 11 for Mac: Search is completely broken.

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.