I am having the same problem with my 3-month old McBook. Its drive is a MATSHITA DVD-R UJ-857
My importing problem seems to have arisen suddently, though that could perhaps just be a coincidence ... I had no problems for several months and then, wham-o, yesterday two CDs in a row froze up on my while importing (with the MacBook sounding like it's working in overdrive). I then used "force quit" - which was very slow to take effect - and tried again and it froze up on the same track each time. I cleaned the CDs, but that didn't help the problem. Tried the same two CDs on another computer and they imported just fine. I agree with everyone that this is a huge problem. Me I don't have another computer and I don't have (and don't want to have to buy!) an external drive.
I'm curious, what's the best Apple has done for folks to date? Sounds like replacing the drive internally doesn't do any good since it's just a flawed model. I wonder, has Apple given anyone an external drive for free to use as a workaround to resolve this issue? You'd think they would, if they are willing to replace whole units, etc.
Hmmm ....
hug drag, this.
liz