Photos out of order in Events after iOS 8 update

I have an iPhone 5s that I just updated to iOS 8. I sync photos from my Aperture library on my Mac, which show up as a "Events From My Mac" album under "Albums" in the Photos app on my iPhone. In iOS 7 and before, events synced from Aperture would show in reverse chronological order, which made sense. Upon updating to iOS 8, all the events are in a random order. I have events from 2008, followed by 2010, then 2009, then 2012, then 2008, etc...


Has anyone else run into this issue? I know that I'll probably have to resort to telling iTunes to stop syncing photos, delete the "iPod Photo Sync" folder from inside the Aperture package, then re-sync all the photos, but before I go through all that trouble, I was hoping someone might have an easy fix.

iMac, OS X Mavericks (10.9.4)

Posted on Sep 17, 2014 4:02 PM

Reply
352 replies

Sep 28, 2014 12:31 AM in response to xtianlaval

xtianlaval wrote:


I have this problem now and had it with the iOS 7 update. It took 4 or 5 updates to iOS 7 to resolve. Right now, not even all photos from an event are syncing to iPhone nor iPad and Key Photo not the same. I imagine Apple thinks I'm doing something wrong. I'm not. I"ve pulled all photos off, re-synced minus some events and it still isn't working. I must admit, 1 event is 6698 photos. That may be too much.

I noticed that with iOS 7, if you were syncing a large number of photos, iTunes would say it had finished syncing but not all the photos would sync. It took me a while to figure out that you just had to hit "Sync" one or two more times to get all the photos to sync over.


As for the key photo, that stopped working a long time ago. I posted about it two years ago here: Key photo not working in iOS and Aperture . As far as I know, key photo syncing broke four years ago and Apple just didn't care.

Sep 28, 2014 9:23 PM in response to alexanderfromsuffolk

alexanderfromsuffolk wrote:


Per AppleCare - if the photos synch and are in the correct events, but the events are out of order, this is considered normal operating behavior at this point.

It is not considered an issue when they appear out of order.

That...can't be right. How does that make any sense?! If a housekeeper comes over to your house to clean and breaks all your windows but tells you, "well, it's not an issue because all the glass pieces are clean," you'd say, "***?!?"


I'm really hoping that you spoke with someone who really didn't know what they were talking about it and that what you heard is not indicative of the attitude people in general at Apple have towards issues.

Sep 29, 2014 1:37 AM in response to mrbofus

How does a bug this obvious get through to the third official master release?


Seriously! It's not like it's a rewrite like in iOS 7, it's just slightly updated. Did someone delete the code where it actually sorts the events by their iPhoto order?


Or did someone else sneak in a events.randomise(); line or something and hoped no one would also notice how glaringly obvious this bug is??

Sep 29, 2014 11:38 AM in response to thre3dee

All I can say is I agree with all of you.

Although my photos are only 3600 big I had a very nice order before and Tim, whilst sniffin' glue obvliously, decided that it doesn't matter how you arrange you photos. At least reading this thread has made me loose more hair than I allready have. Those thin straws of youth are extremely valuable if you, like me, are born Alliende was thrown over 😝

Sep 29, 2014 12:17 PM in response to mrbofus

Having upgraded my iPhone 5 to ios8.0.2 I am still having this sort order issue….it is so unusable that I am holding off buying the 6+ because it was going to be used for displaying my 20,000+ pix from my Mac iPhoto library. Not a reasonable purchase any longer when you can't locate an event/photo to view. In my opinion, this is a far more important item for Apple to address than the "Bendgate" kerfluffle. Come on Apple, get it together!

Sep 29, 2014 5:24 PM in response to mrbofus

Also, MacRumors, Cult Of Mac, AppleInsider and 9to5 Mac.


iOS 8 has introduced a trivial (in programming terms) yet major usability bug in the Photos application causing all synced events under “Events from my Mac” to be shown in a seemingly random order, entirely different from the order shown in iPhoto for OS X. This makes finding events to show friends nigh on impossible.


Every version of iOS to date has shown events in the correct order that reflected the order used in iPhoto as synced through iTunes. Users are now finding it impossible to locate their events to view as not only the order is out of date, the search bar at the top of the “Albums” tab in the Photos app does not use event names as search cues.


With over 12,500 photos neatly organised into events in my Mac’s iPhoto library, I now have to either forgo showing people photos from events, or open an app like Snapseed and use the system’s photo picker control to find the event in its correct order.


This issue seems isolated to only the Photos app. As stated above, the operating system provides a standard control to access photos on users’ phones. This control shows the events in the correct order, where the Photos app does not.


Until Apple fixes this issue, many users including myself have found the Photos app completely useless for viewing photos synced from our computers. As a photographer, I often have to quickly pull up photos or photo shoots on my phone but I simply can’t find my events anymore without scrolling through the entire list to find the event when it is sorted in a random order.


I assume that this is being treated as a bug and not a feature. Perhaps iOS 8.1 will correct the issue, if not it may need to be escalated.

Sep 30, 2014 8:07 AM in response to mrbofus

EUREKA


In the past IOS synced photos from iPhoto based on Events sort order.


With IOS 8 the system appears to sync based on "Photo" which sorts FIRST BY DATE, THEN BY LOCATION. These are the only two tags that the iPhone knows about the photo. The new sort is great for those who have used the "photo shoebox" storage system. For detail freaks like me that have added thousands of untagged photos from many disparate sources and sorted their events by TITLE it creates caos.


The iPhoto app on the computer gives us the tools to edit our events in such fashion as to conform to the new sync procedure. I have edited my event folders adding dates and locations, where needed, so that a DATE/LOCATION sync yields the same sort order as an alphabetical TITLE sort. My 23,451 photos now sync to my IOS devices in my preferred order. Prior to this edit IOS didn't know where to locate untagged photos and they were simply dumped into the current year or even failed to sync and worst of all stopped the sync altogether.


Unfortunately Faces alphabetical sort order remains unchanged (random). Apparently the sort is predicated on the date when the face was first tagged. While it's less desirable than an alphabetical sort, I can live with it.


Actually I commend Apple for addressing a problem for the masses in trying to bring organization. It would have been great if they had explained the ramifications of the change to us detail freaks.


IT WORKS FOR ME! Hope this helps.

Sep 30, 2014 8:32 AM in response to dickscw

Not sure what you're getting at, but if I understand you correctly, you seem to be saying that events from iPhoto on my Mac should sync correctly if they are organized chronologically and by place. Unfortunately, this is not the case. Every one of my 11,000 pics has location information and all my events are synced chronologically on iPhoto on my mac, but the events seem to be random in the photos app on the iPhone. This is not acceptable. Why is it that the app PhotoSync can organize my events chronologically correct on the iPhone, but the photos app cannot? Again, NOT ACCEPTABLE.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Photos out of order in Events after iOS 8 update

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.