Maxipeg wrote:
StarTraveler, what do you think an average iDevice user will do if he gets a notification that an update is available? Apple products happen to provide an excellent user experience out of the box, so why not expect it from an update that is endoresed by Apple?
In answering that we look at this from the standpoint of the 500 million iOS devices that are out there. From that standpoint, you'll find the vast and overwhelming majority have no problems at all, and everything works just fine for them. What you have is a very small minority who run into the various and inevitable problems that pop up with major upgrades. I would say you're dealing with probably way less than ONE PERCENT who have encountered a problem of one kind or another. Of that very small minority, you'll have a significant number who will be able to fix those problems themselves, as we've already seen here. Then you'll find others in that very small minority who will have Apple Support help them. Finally you'll have a very tiny amount who will benefit by a series of revisions, which are typically done after a major upgrade.
NOW ... the question here is to the issue of whether Apple acts to intrude upon the 99% who will never have any problems at all, to deal with the less than ONE PERCENT who will run into problems. The thing that any normal person would do is ACT ON THE BASIS OF THE 99% ... and then subsequently respond specifically to the less than ONE PERCENT who are having difficulties.
NO ONE in their right mind ... would ever in this life design their own personal actions in this life to "acting out" on the basis of what goes on with LESS THAN ONE PERCENT -- and neither would a big company.
THEREFORE Apple is doing EXACTLY what it should be doing, and that is acting on the basis of the 99% while being prepared to address INDIVIDUALLY the problems of the less than one percent.
I see NO PROBLEMS in the way Apple is dealing with this business of providing upgrades.
Besides, what kind of HAVOC and NIGHTMARES do you expect from rolling back to a previous OS? When iOS4 wrecked my iPhone 3G, that was a nightmare. I would have been happy to be able to return to iOS3
It's a numbers thing ... you deal with the very small minority who are having problems and you solve them, but you DO NOT add another entire level of problems from people bricking their machines from going backwards, and being insecure from going backwards, and the incompatibility of apps that automatically update, and they now don't work any longer from going backwards. That's taking the NUMBERS presently there for existing problems and then creating about TEN TIMES MORE PROBLEMS from the bad and unsupported process of going backwards.
Again, it's purely NUMBERS ... which means you will do nothing but dramatically INCREASE user troubles from doing this, which then falls back on Apple for even allowing such a thing (which, of course, they never will).