Hey guys, so just an update:
I made an appointment at the Apple Store Genius Bar today to get my iPhone 6 checked out
I showed them that the screen clicks (made the Apple dude touch my iPhone) and he found that it indeed does click
I also showed him that the volume UP button has sunk in
Also while at the Apple Store, the Apple Genius noticed the front-facing camera was misaligned (showing a sort of a half-moon on the ride side)
Apple decided that the iPhone 6 had some manufacturing defects and instead of attempting to fix it, they would just give me a brand new device - which I am currently now using.
This does not count as an accidental damage - it was completely free of charge and I still have warranty on the iPhone until 2015!
The new replacement iPhone 6 that I received is perfect!