My computer is running very slowly. In my investigation, I have run across a product named ETRECHECK and wonder if it is okay to download and run to get an idea of where the deficiency is located. Is it safe/smart to do that? I'm running El Capitan.
iMac, OS X Mavericks (10.9.4)
QuietMacFan wrote:
I would ask: if it's safe why isn't it in the App Store ?
Because many of the operations it performs do not work properly when run from the Mac App Store sandbox. Plus, it is funded solely through user donations when are not allowed in the Mac App Store. I have plans for a couple of related apps that can run in the Mac App Store, but writing apps takes time.
you likely have 0 license using apps not found in app store, therefore if the app suddenly decides to download your personal data: you have 0 legal recourse
unless you know software well you should stick to Apple's defaults (which is to download apps from the appstore)
Apple's default settings are to download apps from the "Mac App Store and identified developers". Etresoft, Inc. is such an identified developer and EtreCheck is signed with my developer ID. If it were performing any malicious activity, Apple could revoke the certificate at any time.
I've made an iPhone app with xcode following a tutorial. It's easy - and the process to register the app with appstore is built in to xcode. (it's not as if getting into the app store is an unusual step that takes allot of effort)
Developing a useable app with decent functionality is far from easy. Getting into the App Store is harder still. Typically this takes months or years of work. A Mac app is an order of magnitude harder than an iPhone app.
i've seen etrecheck pushed very hard in the community channels and i would back away a little, unless you've read the source code or understand apple very well, from anything not on the Apple servers which someone is pushing you to use
also: my iMac always works from day one without any tinkering. whatever is wrong is maybe because you've been installing non-appstore apps
People here on Apple Support Communities recommend EtreCheck because it helps them solve people's problems over a web site. One of the primary things EtreCheck does is identify other 3rd party apps that cause problems. One the problem is resolved, EtreCheck is designed to be easy to remove.
my final word on your etrecheck is: maybe maybe not. but i do not have time to read that source code (one of 100,000 codes online) to tell you. such projects are usually meant to do good. i can say %100 for sure that microsoft products meant to "clean and repair systtems" released by indie (individuals) have a record of damaging the OS more than helping it.
...
actaully i took a closer look. on the outside nothing bad is apparent HOWEVER.
no xcode project file comes with it
the author does not offer the source code to look at
Your claim that EtreCheck "does not offer the source code to look at" is false. Here is its Github project: GitHub - etresoft/EtreCheck: Source code for EtreCheck. The source includes an Xcode project file that can be used to compile EtreCheck on any recent Mac with Xcode.
If you are going to make a claim that EtreCheck is malicious and not "meant to do good", then you will need to back that up with some facts.
the website appears like it was made in 2 minutes
I'm sorry that you do not find the EtreCheck web site appealing. It is designed to be useful, informative, and work on web browsers of any Mac made in the past decade. It is also designed to load quickly on a Mac that is having problems. For that reason, it is rather simple and not very flashy. It works on both desktop and mobile browsers. It is localized in French and English, automatically detecting the user's language preference. I would challenge anyone to do all of that in 2 minutes. I would be happy to hear any substantive and constructive suggestions for improvement.
i have to say no: it's not safe. heed apple's advice until you have warrantees / guarantees or compiled it yourself
Again, if you have any evidence that EtreCheck is not safe, then provide it or retract your statement. If you want to compile it yourself, you are free to do so. Apple has made no advice whatsoever suggesting that EtreCheck is not safe. EtreCheck is frequently used and recommend here on Apple Support Communities and elsewhere. If it had any "nasty viruses" I'm sure someone would have said something by now.
Disclaimer: Although EtreCheck is free, there are other links on my site that could give me some form of compensation, financial or otherwise.
One additional comment I would like to add, and this applies to any software,
only download the app from either the MacApp Store or DIRECTLY from the
vendor site. Although that does not guarantee that the app itself is any good,
it will limit the possibility of "piggy backed" crapware, or worse.
Coachdl wrote:
My computer is running very slowly. In my investigation, I have run across a product named ETRECHECK and wonder if it is okay to download and run to get an idea of where the deficiency is located. Is it safe/smart to do that? I'm running El Capitan.
Yes, it is safe to download. Many times, an EtreCheck report can help us diagnose problems with that individual's system. Sometimes we need to use EtreCheck and log extracts, and sometimes the EtreCheck report doesn't shed any light on the problem. It depends on what your particular problem is. We won't know until we see it. Sometimes it ends up solving some other problem altogether, something you didn't even know was amiss.
In short, EtreCheck is a perfectly safe, perfectly valid program that you can download and install without worrying about compromising your system. No one here would ask anyone to utilize a program that would damage or corrupt your computer.
Hi Coachdl,
I'm sorry you're having issues. I downloaded Etrecheck and it is not slowing down my computer at all. I say go for it. If your mac is slowing down, you might have too many applications installed on it because when I installed Etrecheck my computer is perfectly fine. I'm on the same version mac as you are. Go for it.
Reply to QuietMacFan
Dude, you are so far off base.
But no one is required to run EtreCheck, it just helps us in these forums so much.
Linc's approach was to provide raw "Data". EtreCheck's approach is to provide useful "Information". Giving someone Data is easy. Turning Data into useful Information is the hard part.
Hello userjulio,
Please start your own thread to discuss yur problem. In that thread please describe the problem you are experiencing and explain when it started. EtreCheck is almost non-functional on your machine. You may need to restart, boot into safe mode, etc. just to be able to run it.
Yes, it is. You’ll likely need to post the report to these boards.
(139944)
It has been used by countless posters on this forum to remedy issues and has worked wonders. It's safe and effective.
EtreCheck is a very safe app to use.
I have run EtreCheck on this Mac and found it to be very safe.
Similar issues too. EtreCheck's okay, it's a diagnostic app.
Just downloaded it. It gave me a report on some malware, which I removed with a click and all is well after a restart. Highly recommend it!
I'm pleased you found some time to answer the criticism.
.
That's useful input - Malwarebytes for Mac is also well regarded by many users, good to hear it worked.
Is Etrecheck a safe app?
