You can make a difference in the Apple Support Community!

When you sign up with your Apple Account, you can provide valuable feedback to other community members by upvoting helpful replies and User Tips.

Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Email forwarding issue

Here's the scenario, user receives an email with 4 attachments: One PDF file, one DOCX and two email messages attached to it. Inside each one of these two message attachments there's an Excel file attached.

User then forwards that message.

The resulting email is a message with two attachments, One corrupted PDF file the doesn't open and a 1K htm file.

This is on an iPhone 6s running iOS 9.3.1 and the native Apple Mail client. Connected to an Exchange 2010 backend via MobileIron.

I've tested the same steps with other ActiveSync email client for iOS and did not experience the problem.


Has anyone came across this issue?


Thanks


Andre

iPhone 6s, iOS 9.3.1

Posted on Apr 13, 2016 9:11 AM

Reply
47 replies

Apr 18, 2016 5:33 AM in response to andre-ldn

We are experiencing the same issue with Exchange 2010 SP1 and iPhones running 9.3.1, using the native Apple Mail client.

When the iPhone user forwards the message (with doc/docx and jpeg attachments) the recipient gets the email but the attachments are corrupted.

We have tested the same using the MS Outlook iOS app and it works fine.

Apr 19, 2016 11:00 AM in response to andre-ldn

We are experiencing the same issue here. Running Exchange 2013 on the back-end with MobileIron and ActiveSync. After much troubleshooting, I was able to isolate this down to the iPhone and iPad native mail application. Both devices running 9.3.1.


I found this though, if you select a email with attachments, select "Forward" > "Include Attachments", then scroll down to the bottom of the newly composed forwarded message, you should now see what attachments are actually going to be forwarded to the recipient before the message leaves the device.


For us, a message with 3 PDF's would sometimes get stripped of 2, or would include all 3. Again, this was before hitting send on the newly composed forwarded message. It was also never consistent.


I have also so far only experienced this with PDFs.

Apr 27, 2016 4:56 AM in response to andre-ldn

Quick update: the user was hitting forward as soon as the message popped into his Mailbox and this was how I've been testing but if I download and view all the attachments (those XLSX inside the MIME attached messages as well) and hit forward, the behavior changes and only the attached emails are stripped off and both the PDF and DOCX file are sent out correctly. Interesting but still not great.

Apr 28, 2016 7:40 AM in response to andre-ldn

The following was posted by a member on ILTA's forums:


"Scenario: You use an iPhone or iPAD with latest version 9.3 iOS. You receive a message with certain multiple attachments and immediately forward it to others to review.

Problem: The multiple attachments you sent may be combined into a single attachment when the recipient gets it.

If received by recipient in Outlook: In most circumstances the received attachment attempts to open and reports a failure.

If received by recipient on Mobile Device: Sometimes you can open it and see the first attachment and not others. Other times the attachment opens with a blacked out window. Other times the attachment doesn’t even show up.

WORK AROUND: We have determined that if you first open the pdfs of the iPhone before forwarding, they always arrive intact.

TIP: If you receive an email on iPhone with multiple attachments and you don’t want to open each one, you can first forward to yourself and see if they come across as they should. If they come intact to you, you can forward to others. If it is corrupt on your device you will either have to either forward using Outlook or take the time to open each original before using the iPhone to forward to effect a successful transmission. We see some limited posts on the Internet but nothing concrete as to the root cause.

If your curious about the details thus far – here is where we are with testing:

It is a result of the iPhone Forward function verses the receive function. It can happen on internal communications so nothing to do with transmission over the net or how someone else's system is configured or how they go about attaching the docs.

We conducted over 100 tests to try and nail down the offending attachment formats. PDF version 1.4 and 1.7 seem to fail all the time. PDF 1.5 which is created by our Nuance app has been solid and works unless a 1.4 or 1.7 version attachment is on the email as well. We have found a few suspect 1.5 files recently however...

We got it to fail with image files only. If only Word docs were attached, thus far it seems fine. If we mixed word docs in with problem pdf or problem image files we could again reproduce the trouble and the word doc was no longer usable.

We know we hit trouble whenever the recipient of the iPhone attachment displays this on their iPhone:

This message was downloaded as plain text.

Download full message

We can 100% replicate the problem with our own email communications within the firm – eliminates the need to test with outside firms. We can duplicate with pdf files attorneys created in-house via Westlaw research (generates Apache origination with PDF version 1.4). I can also reproduce it with a technical document I received from Mimecast.

I cannot duplicate with Nuance PDF converted documents which is what we use and generates the version 1.5 documents. We created and attached dozens without error multiple times.

It is ONLY reproducible on the iOS platform. The Blackberry and Android devices do NOT exhibit this behavior.

We have also replicated it on a iPAD device with the newest 9.3 iOS version.

We have replicated with mail boxes on our existing 2010 exchange server and our new 2016 server which we are migrating to.

We have also replicated with picture files that I had downloaded to my c drive from my iphone.

We can reproduce it on multiple carriers (AT&T and Verizon for example)

We can replicate it on both wi-fi and cellular networks."

May 5, 2016 5:37 AM in response to andre-ldn

I am seeing this issue on our devices too, only started in the last week or so. Has anyone had any response from Apple on this issue or tied it down to any external factor? I have been able to replicate the issue using outlook.com accounts on the devices too so it's not just related to exchange accounts.

Email forwarding issue

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.