Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Apple TV 4 pauses streaming after ~5secs

As the title says my ATV4 simply pauses the streaming after about 5 seconds of playback, in any application. I've tried YouTube, Apple Events, TED, Plex. It's all the same. If I resume the playback it starts again instantly, but it would pause again after another 5 seconds And so on. It's not a network issue, I have it now connected on Ethernet and the speed test shows an expected 94Mbps and other devices on the same network work just fine. I've even tried to reset it to factory settings, it still does the same thing. I thought it might be the remote, I took it out of range and used an iPhone remote app, no change. Even more infuriating the issue comes and goes with no appparent reason. The ATV might work perfectly well for a week then out of the blue it would simply pause any playback after 5 seconds. Then after a few hours or days it will start to work properly again.

I have no idea what to do anymore, anybody else experienced something similar?

Apple TV, tvOS 9.2

Posted on Apr 21, 2016 4:37 PM

Reply
27 replies

Apr 24, 2016 5:08 AM in response to Diana.McCall

Hmmm... the TV is a rather old Samsung (~10 years) that does have HDMI-CEC, only that it's working erratically. I tried get it to recognise the ATV as a CEC-Player so that it shuts down the TV when it goes into sleep mode, it worked at some point, but now it refuses to connect as CEC. BUT pressing the play/pause buttons on the TV remote did pause/resume the ATV, even as I couldn't get it to connect as CEC. After that it even shut down the TV when I put the ATV to sleep. I'll investigate further on this when the ATV starts to misbehave next time and report back.


Thanks for all your help.

Apr 25, 2016 2:14 PM in response to dcbinsomniac

Ok, another oddity. Last night although it wasn't pausing at all, it wouldn't scroll back or forward. Nothing happened at all when you tried to scroll. The 10sec skip worked, a few times, until at some point if you tried to skip another 10secs it would exit the playback.


On the other hand I might have made some progress, although I have no explanation for it and it might simply be random. So tonight it started again to do the pause thing. As vazandrew suggested to check the DNS, I did and it was on automatic, pointing to the main DNS of the local network (a caching DNS server). So I thought to try something different. I happen to have a PlexConnect daemon that runs it's own DNS server (it only actually alters some IPs otherwise it forwards all requests to the main DNS server). I pointed the ATV 4 to this DNS and it started working instantly 🙂. I will try later to make some tests using public DNS servers.


May 1, 2016 10:55 AM in response to dcbinsomniac

dcbinsomniac, I am adding this since I had the exact same problem since 9.3. I don't think the problem is related to anything posted here. Here is why:


1. I have 2 Apple TV 4 64GB. One works fine since 9.3, the other will only play music or YouTube for 45 seconds to almost 5 minutes. Most often close to 1 minute then stops.


2. The only difference was that the one that failed uses ethernet, the working one wifi. So, I changed from wired to ethernet, rebooted, power off. Nothing changed, still did not work.


3. The wireless is an Airport Extreme used in bridge mode, I use a Zyxel USG100 as the house router which is excellent. Since both ATVs get their DNS from the router they are the same. But still one works and one does not, so it's not DNS related at least for me.


4. This was a solid problem since 9.3, nothing I could do would change anything. Last night, we figured we would test watch an HBO Now show and assumes it would not last, same as other apps. Oddly, HBO Now worked fine for over 2 hours!


5. The fun fact: After the HBO Now stuff, I tried Apple Music and it stayed on! Left it on for 30 minutes, then changed to another Radio selection. It stayed working the entire evening. Keep in mind this is after never working properly since 9.3. As I write this I am playing AM to test it and it's still running fine.


So After weeks of only 1 Apple TV 4 not letting play music or YouTube for more than a couple of minutes it "fixed" itself after playing HBO Now. I did not test other apps. We just figured we would have to wait until 9.3.1. I am opening a problem with Apple Monday and advise you to do the same since a lot of people gripe here but never call Apple to let them know. Please report this so Apple.

May 1, 2016 11:33 AM in response to Mario MG

Hello Mario,

Could please clarify a couple of things.

I don't understand the second sentence of item 2. You say that you switched the failed ATV from wired to ethernet and it didn't help. Do you mean that you tried it on WiFi and that didn't help?

Is the ethernet connection to the router or to the AirPort? It might make a difference.

Are you running your own DNS, or just using what the router gets from your ISP? This symptom (dropping server connection) really does seem to point to a DNS problem of some kind.

When you look at the ATV network settings, do they make sense? No bogus IPs, etc.?

I assume you haven't created some sort of conflict using static IPs.

May 1, 2016 12:19 PM in response to Mario MG

Forgot to mention the one that had the problem was connected HDMI to a VP50 video processor connected to a Pioneer Kuro plasma, the working one to a samsung TV. Totally different units and been like that since the ATV4s were purchased a day apart. So I am pretty sure HDMI is not the issue.


Airplay problems also started with 9.3, in fact, at first I thought it was only Airplay related until we tried to play Apple Music from the ATV.

* Airplay to stops in about 1 minute no matter what I am playing. On both Apple TV 4s.

* Youtube App playing on Apple TV 4 now works fine. So HBO Now fixed it as well.

* Retested Apple Music and it's still fine. This occurs on both Apple TV 4s so it seems this is unrelated to the issue of Apple Music and other streaming.


Airplay has been useless since TVOS 9.1. 9.3.1 is around the corner and wonder if it will fix Airplay. Either way I am calling Apple and report this since 9.3.1 may not fix the issue with Airplay and they should know about the HBO Now fix.

May 1, 2016 12:24 PM in response to Diana.McCall

Diana, I am a computer/network person, for 30+ years. Except for the AE everything is commercial networking, HP switch, Zyxel router. I can guarantee it's not DNS. There are over 50 network devices in the house. The Airport is in bridge mode so it would not make a difference since the AE is not engaging in DNS or routing in any way. Oh yes, my bad, I switched from wired to wifi and no change. Only Airplay is broken now.

May 1, 2016 3:16 PM in response to Mario MG

OK. Your network configuration sounds great. I looked up your VP50, and it doesn't sound like it would have HDCP troubles. (Some users have HDMI to VGA converters for their older projectors, but those gizmos are meant for classroom use, and they don't support HDCP.)


So, lets try and help your AirPlay problem, because it's not a universal failure.

What happens when AirPlay stops? Does ATV cancel the connection, causing the sending device to turn off AirPlay? Can you turn AirPlay back on at the sender, or is ATV gone from the menu? Or does playback simply stop?

Have you given the ATVs different names? This seems obvious, but some users overlook it.

Have you tried AirPlay mirroring from a phone or Mac? Does ATV drop that connection as well?

I only know of two reasons for ATV to drop AirPlay like that. One is if it doesn't have an HDCP connection, but that will be instantaneous - on and back off immediately. The other more likely case is that it loses the connection to the server. Remember that video ATV actually connects to the server itself and plays the stream. So ATV needs access to the internet and reliable DNS. Or if you're playing from a local server, ATV needs to connect to it. The OP did mention that he identified a problem with his nameservers that seemed to cause his problem.

Could you describe the simplest AirPlay configuration that fails? Maybe AirPlay from YouTube app on iPad?

May 2, 2016 10:02 AM in response to Diana.McCall

Thanks for trying to help, but I have had 5 Apple TVs for years and know them well. I even found DHCP flooding for Apple in a network trace so Apple could fix it. There is another reason for Airplay to not work.... there is a bug in TVOS. This has happened before where it would not work for months until Apple fixed it. I just called Apple about it.

Jun 8, 2016 2:13 PM in response to dcbinsomniac

Ok, so several weeks later after changing the DNS to manual as I've explained in my previous post I have not experienced the streaming pause issue anymore.

BUT, to me the ATV 4 is a piece of junk and I'm curious if it's only my device or the sort of problems I'm experiencing are "normal":

1) The worst was the stream pause issue which seems to be solved with the manual DNS

2) It never ever shows the stream download indicator in any application whatsoever. I only have the thin scroll bar with no download indicator.

3) Sometimes the remote behaves strange, the trackpad only senses up and maybe down, but almost no left/right. You got to fight your way to where you want to get on the screen. Sometimes I just give up and use the remote app on the iPhone..

4) It randomly refuses to scroll. It just won't move the time indicator. The solution is a restart.

Nov 21, 2016 5:34 PM in response to dcbinsomniac

I had this same issue. For me, the issue was being caused by my mac laptop trying to connect to my atv4. It was not as straight forward as airplay being turned on, however my audio output settings had been set to use the apple tv. The issue was resolved as soon as i switched my laptop back to use the internal speakers.

This is not a network issue as many have eluded to. Troubleshooting this issue drove me bonkers, but in the end it makes sense that another devices was causing the ATV to pause video. If you are having this issue, check other devices and make sure they are not connected to your ATV.

Apple TV 4 pauses streaming after ~5secs

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.