Spotlight's CPU usage is out of control for no reason
I'm finding more and more Macs running 10.11.4 where Spotlight is just out of control for no reason that I can discern.
If no one is logged in, Spotlight is using no CPU.
As soon as someone logs in, Spotlight takes over as the number one CPU usage process. It's currently at 166.4% (of multiple cores).
It doesn't matter if I disable mdutil and kill Spotlight... Spotlight comes back and eats CPU.
Reboots don't matter.
10.11.4 Combo reinstall didn't help.
Clearing out Caches didn't help. /System, /Library, and /Users.
Create a brand new user and login, Spotlight jumps to the top spot.
Safe boot, Spotlight jumps to the top.
Network cable out, no difference.
First-Aid was clean when booted from the Recovery Partition.
What the heck is going on here?
OS X El Capitan (10.11.4)