It depends whether you mean make more "Apple sense" or actual sense...
It makes Apple sense as Apple never recall anything ("You're holding it wrong", for example) - but it doesn't make actual sense as the Genius needed to see the serial # of my keyboard to confirm it was once of the 'identified batch'. Given that there *is* an 'identified batch' (otherwise why would she need to spend 10 mins trying to read the serial # printed on the felt underside of the unit?) then extending the warranty by any length of time to wait to see if a product that has already been identified as faulty fails seems somewhat disingenuous. That just suggests that it *should* have been recalled, but wasn't.
But, like I say, that makes complete "Apple sense".
It's a moot point as the message was to suggest to anyone else suffering the issues I did - as they seem to be doing in this thread - simple take the iPad and keyboard to an Apple store, let the genius figure out if it's a faulty one and simply swap it out rather than going through the mandatory reboot, soft reset, hard reset, clean the contacts, spin around three times, do a rain dance, pass magnets in a Raki-like manner over the devices and say "there's no place like home!" to see if that solves the problem.