Paikinator
The Battery is the entire issue.
The only solution is that the Batteries must be replaced. There is simply no other possible answer and therefore everything else is mere flailing around by a bunch of nincompoops and ignoramus' who won't believe him or take his advice to spend money on a "Apple" only battery replacement.
[~Belisarius
Thank you for this splendid example of poor critical thinking. First, you build strawman arguments- words myself or no one else said, then you take them apart. It is highly indicative of very poor deductive logic.]
I never did say you used those exact words. No strawman at all…. neither is this any example of poor critical thinking on my part but thanks for trying to point out a flaw in my person.
My comment is paraphrasing the gist of your entire arguments since you started posting. A simple distillation of what you have posted since page 66 of the 79 pages thus far.
i.e. the battery is the issue causing this; you need to replace the battery to solve this issue
[NOWHERE HERE ONE HAS ADVISED TO SPEND MONEY as a solution- in fact, most iPhone 6s owners are covered by warranty still;]
De Facto pushing first for people to get a new battery as the primary solution is telling people to spend money. People with iphone 5’s 5s’s 6, 6plus’ are all suffering from this issue and yet the lone solution presented is a battery upgrade. Further is the insinuation that people are daft if they don’t hit the genius bar and get their batteries replaced.
Of course owners who still are under warranty have greater options for getting a phone or a new battery. It is widely known that 6S owners are covered so this point adds nothing to the discussion. All non-6S owners have also been encouraged to get batteries as the primary solution. Commentary was not specific to 6s owners in other words. So that would necessitate spending money to replace their batteries by a large number of people on this thread. Fact.
Pounding home the point of the need to swap out batteries in at least 10 postings ellucidates the stance of Belisarius. Further in the postings is the suggestion that to not replace the battery is wasting time. There was a claim of being here forums despite not personally experiencing the issue to help forum members “better utilize their time” by “guiding” them to battery replacement.
[nor has anyone called the audience names as you just did.]
Merely more paraphrasing to show the intent of Bellisarius’ postings. The view of those who don’t agree with the position taken is to denigrate them as illogical and incapable of thinking. Hence nincompoops and ignoramus’
[Also, no one has argued that the battery alone is at fault.]
Note: There was a Beisarius and a ~Belisarius.
Same person? 2 user accounts for the same person? I don’t know.
Beisarius - First post was page 66. Suggested Apple would be coming up with a fix soon.
Page 69
The first suggestion by Beisarius is to go the genius bar and get a new phone. (Nearest one for me is 2 1/2 hours away) Great and expensive option for most people.Especially given that this could simply be an update issue.
Also suggest that users are at fault for running “energivore” apps or social media.
Pretty much every post beyond page 69 is an intensifying effort to bring up the issue about batteries being at fault in some manner. So much for the idea that Apple will come up with a fix or skip calling apple and run to the genius bar to get your new phone. Now one needs to run to the genius bar and get a new battery strait away.
There is a questioning as to why people are trying to resolve an issue that is not resolveable by consumers….
Most of what is said in the next 10 pages of commentary is about batteries, battery controllers, battery drain over multiple generations of phones proving that the battery is the issue, firmware updates hosing the batteries, OS upgrades hosing the batteries. Lots of crummy analogies about batteries.
Over the last 10 pagesdiscussion by ~Belisarius has revolved around batteries alone with the claim of being on these forums to help guide people to better utilize their time by getting a battery replacement.
[But that, once all initial steps concluded, i.e. Apple Call, Hard factory reset, etc, the battery is the only next logical step, and most likely to solve the issue.]
There is no mention by Belisarius about doing a reset as a means of solving the issue.
Others have posted about success with resets before ~Belisarius started commenting. And after those factory resets the battery began functioning again without spontaneous crashes thus indicating that there might not be an actual battery issue in some cases.
[It already has for countless of forum posters since the launch of the initial iPhone. Yes, for 9 years some peple have battery issues and had them resolved. And each forum level, each year, someone thretened and blamed Apple. We all laughed..]
There is no dispute that people having battery issues have had them resolved. The discussion has been whether the issue this time is an actual battery issue or not. You say yes it seems, I say perhaps for some people the battery may be the problem, but perhaps there could be other causes. It is too early to tell and too complicated for a one-size fits all solution. For some a battery swap may work, for some a factory reset may work, for some an iOS fix may be in the offing.
Why?
Success with a battery swapis only for some. For others a battery swap has not helped. The issues are complicated and varied.
Threatening and blaming Apple?
People have a right to be upset when their expensive phones stop being functional after an update. They also have a right to feel the blame lies with Apple. They own Apple phones developed by Apple running software developed by Apple. Threatened Apple? Really?
Most people seem to have said they may seek another phone. That is a choice not a threat.
[Another lapse in judgment: your not realizing that SPENDING MONEY ON THE BATTERY IS 100% RISK FREE. Since Apple guarantees it working or full refund. 100$. Vs 1100$ for a new working phone.]
Key word… “spending money” on a Battery. If some find a solution without spending money because of swapping the battery, then they have a better solution available.
Has nothing to do with judgement or not on my part, but you keep wanting to make this about me and my brain processes.
There are other solutions that work sometimes. And perhaps a software update will provide a solution for others in the future. Perhaps the 10.2 update already helps those who do a factory reset where 10.1.1 provided no such help. And perhaps some have a true battery issue as you propose.
But even when those who choose to swap the battery do so, perhaps the fix is not actually the battery, but rather something about the reboot and reset process which clears out whatever got glitched out when 10.1.1 was installed.
Thus perhaps not a Battery issue at all, but people had to spend on a battery regardless. Seems like it is hard to say at this point what caused the problem and what ultimately is responsible for fixing it. Software, OS, Hardware, battery, controller.
[What do you have to say to that? Because no one will fix for free those 10x e-6 defective units out there or 40 000 or so units a year. If you have Apple Care, sure. If not, Apple employees are fairly generous at buying back your partially working phone and discounting a new phone.]
All of this costs money when the problem could simply be an OS update issue. Being cavalier with other peoples money is easy.
[So yes, with academics and reading, and learning, it takes seconds to return to this page and call out anger mongering, negativity, blame finger pointing and no constructive solution option.]
My solution is working on my 5.
IHIP699 solution worked on his iPhone posted well before Belisarius came to this forum.
Those ARE constructive solutions.
Repeating for 10 pages that people need to swap out their batteries seems to be browbeating others. The battery swap solution has been noted by others prior to any post by Belisarius. Likewise battery swap not working or partially working has been posted.
[Since you blame Apple in your entries, yes, your solution can de dissected as nagging finger pointing.]
Nonsense. The solution still is solution perhaps for those who have a 5.
Simply noting that OS’s can lead to various bugs has been well documented and is not nagging finger pointing or blaming Apple. Apples phones and their software are made by Apple. If something goes buggy with an update who should the blame be assigned to, the buyer?
Anyhow, these are complicated systems and I don’t waste time assigning blame. I have said so in most of what I post here and elsewhere. Trying to assign such sentiments to me is misguided and your own issue not mine.
And since Apple corrects bugs frequently by issuing updates there seems a de facto acknowledgement that bugs can cause various issues and updates can resolve such issues. That is reality… not blame.
So No Fingerpointing. My ongoing work for a solution may work for others perhaps.
[As for commenting on Apple batteries, this is a serious mistep on your behalf. Anyone putting non-Apple batteries in their phones not only are unlikely to get them to work, but are nulifying any warranty and more likely to fry their entire phone.]
Commenting of the batteries is a mistep???
Not sure what the meaning is about, but perhaps this reference is to Batteries plus?
Well since most phones affected are out of warranty “voiding the warranty” is impossible. If the phone is under warranty you simply replace the battery for free.
As to Batteries being installed by such large businesses whose prime function is selling batteries, I believe that hundreds of thousands of iPhone owners have done so at large repair shops with great success. Since they offer a warranty for 6 months, it seems unlikely that Batteries Plus would go to all of that effort of putting the batteries into the iPhones if the batteries don’t work at allor indeeddestroy their clients iPhones as is your assertion.
Anyhow, do you have a reason to think the Batteries used by Batteries plus are bad? Have any data to say a Batteries Plus battery won’t work in the phone or will fry it? In fact aren’t many 3rd party batteries manufactured by the same factories on the same assembly lines as Apple’s own batteries?
[The advie offered, and my Christmas time generosity gift for you, is to save people's time.]
A redundant postsarenot a Gift. Badgering people on a forum when oneisn’t even dealing with the issue being discussed oneself and berating the motivations and intelligence of those who are coming for answers and participating in the discussion is a waste of other peoples time. Feeling the need to post 25% of the posts on roughly 13 and counting pages doesn’t help a discussion group. But to each his own I suppose. Keep posting. It is your time.
[ The sequence is as fol:
- Factory reset, with or without Apple Sr support
- Risk free battery replacement and trial, paid or under Apple Care (no cost)]
Nice to see you finally mention Factory Reset first finally.
Others including myself have been posting about this as a possiblesolution many of pages before Belisarius got here. Nice to see you finally change your mind .
Funny that your first solution sequence based on your posts was different.
1. Apple will come up with a fix pretty soon so don’t rag on Apple
2. Don’t call apple about it go to a genius bar and get a new phone.
3. get a new battery cause that is what is causing the problem of apparent rapid battery depletion and spontaneaous shutdowns.
4. Get a new battery cause faulty controllers, firmware, etc caused the battery to fail during the stressful update.
5. And now below… you will need a new phone because this particular phone revealed what a crummy phone you have had for the 3-4 years. hahahahaha
[If these fail, guess what? The phone maybe the issue- for whatever reason. 40 000 a year/240 million, you drew the lotto..]
????? Not helpful.
[Any comments? What is your advice? Besides whinning, blaming Apple or accusing forum members for defending Apple with neutral facts?]
Yep.
I have posted 6 updates about my experience and probably will post some more over the next few weeks as my experience with this real issue evolves.
No whinning. Speaking ones mind and whinning are not equivalent.
No blaming Apple. Stating how things happen is reality
But I will definitely call out members who badger other people on the forums and are not contributing significantly to the discussion. I have 6 updates to my experience.