Macbook 2016 stuck in an update loop

Hello Johankman,

Thank you so much for your resolution, I tried everything but finally this one worked!!

Bests,

Iris

I'm in contact with support for almost a month. Always some attempt to solve but nothing solved yet.

For my case they believe it is a network issue that generated the problem. So they asked me to try on a different network but no solution yet.

I have been in touch with Apple they recommended me also to be in touch With an Apple premium reseller. The technician told me my macbook pro is an illegal version as this pop up at the start is a malware and only updates go through mac store not from the start

Resetting up all will incur a cost what a joke Apple!

In my case, the advice that the problem is due to malware, is probably not accurate. I purchased my macbook pro with touchbar directly from the apple education store online. After encountering the endless loop, I took advice from this thread and reinstalled the software, erased the disk and reinstalled the software, and changed networks. Nothing helped.

I received the error out-of-the box. I had done nothing more to this new computer than to turn it on.

I contacted Apple via online chat and they walked me through the usual procedures (the ones I'd already undertaken, in addition to demonstrating the ability to start in 'safe mode' but not otherwise). They instructed me to take it to a certified Apple repair shop.

The shop tested the hardware, tried reinstalling the software, and they even installed and attempted to use a new hard drive. They could not get around this error loop.

They returned my macbook to Apple. It is being replaced by a new machine.

If you're encountering the same difficulties, and you've taken steps to reinstall the original OS from scratch and failed to resolve the issue I suggest you take your macbook to a certified Apple repair shop. Upon dropping it off to them, they may suggest that it is only a software/network problem that can be rectified with a new network/installation and that you will be charged for the software issue. My experiences, however, would suggest that this error runs deeper and it is very unlikely that a 'software fix' that they attempt in shop will get around the issue. If my own problem is any indication, they will discover that it can't be addressed in shop and requires replacement.

I know this is frustrating and disappointing. But I found my local apple repair shop to be very helpful. Don't waste too much time trying to fix it on your own if the CMD-R reinstall procedures fail - determination might not get you far.

I am having this problem as well. I do not want to return this one, I already had one die on me after one month. I replaced that. This is a $3,000 computer that is full of issues. The 2016 Macbook is in my opinion full of bugs and not a good buy. I am so frustrated.

Same issue here, I tried tons of things. Always same result -> Boot loop for critical update installation. This is related to EFI and embedded OS for TouchID. I am in contact with Apple Support. They know about issue as my case was escalated and well...now waiting up to Monday to continue resolving.

I tried:

1) New install macOS, create user, run Migration assistant, migrate

2) Delete all partitions with gparted, Internet restore, then follow point 1

3) Do same thing on another same new Mac

4) Try on different internet connection (well download was not an issue)

5) Try with no USB C devices attached

.....

I can see errors about embedded OS upgrade and so on, but I have no clue anymore what else to try on my own.

We tried to migrate some other mac to this machine and everything worked. So it must be related to something specific in existing mac installation. I am on 10.12.4 (old and new).

I can boot into Safe Mode (hold shift down when booting).

I had the issue too. I tried to upgrade the os on safe mode from 10.12.3 to current 10.1.2.4 thinking it would resolve the problem but it did not. I called Apple and did a install over the internet replaceing the OS but that did not work. I tried booting from an external clean 10.12.2 Sierra download but came up with the problem while setting up a new account so I went to the Apple Store and the tech proved it was software related by booting off the network from their 10.12.4. The tech tried to remove some apps that were a potential issue while in safe mode but that did not help. He suggested that maybe the https://www.igeeksblog.com/how-to-disable-system-integrity-protection-on-mac/ system integrity protection was a issue but we skipped all that and blew off all data with disk utility erase and reinstalled the OS 10.12.4 and all went fine after I re migrated the user data and applications from time machine back on again. In conclusion it was not a hardware failure but maybe a situation that was prone to older versions of Sierra. The new touch bar and or touch ID may be the issue because the senior advisor at Apple was given a terminal command from engineering to try to do something with the USB. Here is the command line we typed in while in safe mode

https://arstechnica.com/video/2016/11/the-2016-13-and-15-inch-touch-bar-macbook- pros-reviewed/

Hello!

I also tried that. Blasted whole partition table away, reinstalled Sierra from Internet Recovery, but it did not help either.

I also came to the step with the console command, this is not there to help, it's a command to enable extra debugging. Waiting on Apple Support to come back with more things today....

Another colleague migrated his system without an issue to same device I also tried, so this must be related to something specific in our existing installations....

Same thing happened to me. Stepped away from my 2016 15 inch MBP to return to it rebooting on it's own. Got stuck in a loop saying there is a critical update needed and I can't use my Mac until its installed. Prompts me to select a network, which upon doing so, I get another error and the only options are to retry or reboot. Wash, rinse, repeat. Did Internet Recovery, debugged with AppleCare support, and a complete reformat to no avail (multiple times). Took it to Genius Bar, who shipped it off to Cali. Waiting to learn the results. Smh.

GUYS!!!! I SOLVED IT!!!! I could not wait on Apple, since two weeks already passed and I just had to try....So I debugged, went through a lot of log files, checked EFI partitions....and FINALLY....

After restoring from TimeMachine I checked my /System/Library/Extensions and funny there were a lot of files (use "ls -l") with dates like 2008, 2012 (USB Serial drivers, 3G Modem drivers...) and funny even some really old stuff from Apple:

drwxr-xr-x@ 3 root wheel 102 Jan 12 2009 AppleUSBHub.kext

I first deleted:

drwxr-xr-x@ 3 root wheel 102 Oct 15 2008 NovatelWireless3G.kext

drwxr-xr-x@ 3 root wheel 102 Oct 15 2008 NovatelWirelessFilter.kext

drwxr-xr-x@ 3 root wheel 102 Aug 29 2013 ProlificUsbSerial.kext

drwxr-xr-x@ 3 root wheel 102 Mar 9 2009 RT2870USBWirelessDriver.kext

drwxr-xr-x@ 3 root wheel 102 Jul 11 2007 RBIOKitHelper.kext

drwxr-xr-x@ 3 root wheel 102 Jun 7 2012 UPSVendori386.kext

drwxr-xr-x@ 3 root wheel 102 Oct 15 2008 HuaweiDataCardDriver.kext

drwxr-xr-x@ 3 root wheel 102 Aug 30 2013 Fantom.kext

drwxr-xr-x@ 3 root wheel 102 Dec 23 2008 FTDIUSBSerialDriver.kext

drwxr-xr-x@ 3 root wheel 102 Mar 24 2010 EPSONUSBPrintClass.kext

drwxr-xr-x@ 3 root wheel 102 Jan 15 2006 BJUSBMP.kext

drwxr-xr-x@ 3 root wheel 102 Jan 12 2009 AppleUSBHub.kext

Rebooted....same issue....Then I spoted more and deleted those too:

drwxr-xr-x@ 3 root wheel 102 Aug 30 2012 2.2.0 (Contained Belcarra.USBLAN_netpart.kext...)

drwxr-xr-x@ 3 root wheel 102 Aug 30 2012 3.1.1 (Contained Belcarra.USBLAN_netpart.kext...)

drwxr-xr-x+ 3 root wheel 102 Jan 12 2009 IOUSBCompositeDriver.kext

I think that was all, anyhow no old files were anymore in this directory. Rebooted....BAM...critical update applied and after more than 2 weeks I can finally use my new MacBook Pro!

Something of that messed up the EmbeddedOSInstaller service that repairs things related with TouchID....

Hope that helps!

I found the answer to this. It was typical Mac voodoo after trying all the things that should have worked. My experience was (and this is the second time this has happened, for reasons I can't explain). root took possession of 50 odd folders in Users/xxx/Library, causing all my software to go crazy (I no longer had access). I tried various terminal things to fix it. No dice. So get out the clone!!! I got out my Macbook Pro 2012 (also running Sierra), running Carbon Copy Cloner, and cloned the full hard disk, with the recovery partition. The backup disk was connected to the 2012 via USB 3. The Macbook Pro 2016 was connected in target disk mode (via Thunderbolt to USB C). Clone complete. Booted up the 2016, and I'm ready to go, right? Wrong. "Essential software". Ugh. Why? How it it not be on the clone OR the recovery partition? EVERYTHING was cloned! Gave it my wireless, it spins all night, never stops. I tried reinstalling Sierra from wireless, "Essential software" loop. Spins forever. Then I tried erasing the disk, installing Sierra via wireless. "Essential software" loop. Forever Finally I tried voodoo. Booted the Macbook Pro 2016 in target disk mode. Connected via USB C to Thunderbolt adapter to Macbook 2012 thunderbolt port. Downloaded full Sierra installer to 2012. Installed Sierra from the 2012 onto 2016 via target disk mode thunderbolt to USB C adapter. Boot 2016 machine. Pray. Hey!!!!!!! Uh oh, "essential software". Asks for wireless. Downloads software in 40 seconds, installs in 2 minutes, and we are good to go. I then migrate data from the clone. I am back in business. Hope this helps. I honestly don't know if this actually works or if you just keep installing or downloading "essential software" it eventually works (like spinning a roulette wheel). But it worked for me.

We have three new MacBook Pros in our office and two of them have had this issue within a week of each other. Command-R did not save either of them. Both drives had to be erased and reformatted. We're crossing our finger on the third.

Hi,

I have the exact same reboot loop issue / same error message with my late 2016 15" MacBook Pro. I took it to a Genius Bar and they initially told me that they would keep it overnight and reinstall the OS and this would resolve the issue. The following day they called me to say that it's actually a hardware issue and they have to replace the logic board. It's been a week now and I still don't have my laptop back from Apple.

Regards,

stephen

Hi All,

This turned out to be a hardware problem with the display connecting to the logic board. This was causing a short which in turn caused kernel panics. Apple replaced the logic board (which did not fix the issue) then the display and cabling which resolved the issue.

if you are having this issue I would send your 2016 MacBook Pro back to Apple. I suspect that there might be a design flaw that can cause the display cable to short out the logic board.

Regards,

Stephen

Same problem here. Brand new MBP bricked thanks to this critical update loop. Tried everything from every thread on the subject. Hard to believe that after 9 months of this happening to people, there is still no known solution