Here's my update:
- I got my AirPods before Christmas, walked into a store and bought it off the shelf. Took it home, found out it had the issue, and went back into the Apple Store the next day to complain about the issue. At that time this thread was minimal and both myself and the Genius Bar people thought it was the phone. Their quote, "The AirPods are so new, there is no way it has an issue!!" I had Apple Care and they replaced my phone. Got a new iPhone 6S +. They suggested I start off with a fresh install Instead of restoring my backup. Most of my info is on the cloud, so I went ahead and did that. It cost me a lot of time to restore everything and download my App's, but I really wanted the AirPods to work.
- Fresh iOS install and AirPods only. It worked in Dual AirPod mode for a while, then subsequently started disconnecting again.
- Later that evening I re-setup my Apple Watch (1st gen) and the disconnects kept continuing. More frequently With the watch paired again.
- Last Friday I got a call from someone from Apple representing the Senior Engineers. She took a full interview about the issue, had me install the diagnostic tool, and capture a couple moments when it actually happened.
- I have to say I was super impressed by their level Of detail. It ended up being a 2 hour call. Extremely friendly and you can tell Apple really wants to figure this out. When you get someone friendly like that, it makes you feel happy to assist Apple and hope it gets fixed soon!! I LOVE using my AirPods (so convenient), especially at the gym. These things never fall out And I love The clarity of the music.
Funny thing is during the call with the Apple rep, the AirPods worked like a charm. Couldn't get it to fail for the life of me. Then, of course, we hang up, and 90 seconds into my next call, it disconnects. I was able to capture the data for Apple and upload it for this and another subsequent call.
- They gave me a case number and sent me to a Senior Engineer. He was not aware of the issue and kept calling them EarPods And suggesting I go into the Genius Bar to see if they can help. That's so embarrassing On their behalf. Totally opposite experince compared to the original tech rep. I asked my original rep for a new Senior Engineer to keep me up To date with the progress. No response yet.
- I saw someone comment that it happens to them on FaceTime Audio. I haven't had it disconnect on FaceTime Audio for me. The only time I have a Dual AirPod disconnect is during a native iOS phone call. FaceTime, FaceTime Audio, Spotify, Apple Music, iTunes videoes, iTunes movies, YouTube all work perfect for me on dual AirPod.
There are ways to mitigate the issue (remove Apple Watch pairing, switch the mic to one AirPod only, etc...), but in my experience this only mitigates the issue and does not solve it. I even have disconnects with 1 AirPod in, though much less frequent than 2 AirPods.
I've given a lot of time and data to Apple so I'm hopeful they figure it out! Someone was debating whether to return their AirPods. I love mine for my workouts at the gym, so I'm going to keep it, though it's so frustrating when it disconnects a phone call. If it works like it does for music, it's going to be so great!
Keep submitting a bug report to Apple - they are clearly listening To us. I have no idea what triggered the phone call (this message board or an official bug report). Interestingly they called my home phone line and not my cell phone. I just happened to be home to take the call, so it worked out well.