Dude! I have the same issue! It's with calling people and the headset. I went on the forums to post about it, and saw your post.
So, yesterday I bought the 8 Plus, and got it home. I had problems enabling AT&T WiFi, so I had to call AT&T. During my call, it was crackling and popping the entire call. So I switched it to speaker phone and then it stopped. I then tried to make a test call back to 611, and every time, I could hear this crackling and popping. It's incessant. So, I talked to someone on the Support app after going through Apple's website to troubleshoot the issue, and they said their diagnostic tool didn't find anything wrong with the app, bring it into the store so they can look at it. I brought it back to the store, and they swapped it out for another 8 Plus, but it had the same issue. I asked the technician if she could just get me one of the demo 8 Plus phones and see if it does it, and it that one does it, either the batch sent to this store was defective, or it's a problem with AT&T. She wasn't able to get an 8 Plus demo phone, but she was able to get an 8 phone, and I put my SIM card in and it had the same problem!
However, I've narrowed it down to a software issue. I made a call to a friend for about an hour. (We talked about philosophy/the human condition/trump/something I know would get the conversation heated so the volume in the conversation would rise). The conversation is broken up in 20 minute segments (1/3rd each). The first 20 minutes was held on the ear piece speaker that you put next to your ear. It was crackling and popping the entire time. The next 20 minutes was held on CarPlay. No crackling or popping. The following 20 minutes was held again on the ear piece speaker, no crackling and popping.
This HAS to be a software issue with the 8/8 Plus! I worked with the GoldSrc video game engine before, and this sounds like an artifact when the packet alignment bytes are wrong or out of sync, and the compression algorithm compensates for this by just interpolating the signal. However, cellphone signals are very noisy, something around the 98 dB SNR rate. This means there's a lot of garbage that needs to be filtered out, most of it done in software. I BELIEVE that the baseband modem is just not doing its job right, and that is what is causing this popping we are hearing.