It's still about choice and laptops don't do that - the iphone 6 does!
Let's get real - we know that mechanical hard drives fail - it is a risk, that's why we take backups of our critical data. But with power on laptops the user can manage power features from CPU usage to suspending USB ports and just about every other battery saving feature - we have choice and almost infinite reconfigurability of the power saving features. We have no say currently on the performance-throttling situation with the iPhone.
Now, had Apple instead opted to say something like the following, do you really think we'd be having law suits, class action and thousands of complaints if they had been upfront and honest to start with?
"Hey everybody, we'd like to share something truly remarkable with you today.... (š) We'd like to tell you that our incredibly designed iPhone hardware and software has a bug, flaw, design fault new feature. When your battery starts to get old, is not fully charged, or cannot hold a full charge any more, it may cause your phone to malfunction or crash. However, this new feature we are introducing will automatically reduce CPU / GPU performance of the phone to prevent this happening. We appreciate this is not what you want to hear and realise that your phone will start slowing down, the keyboard response will lag, apps will crash or stop working - but hey! we are giving you the choice to enable or disable this feature - so you are always in charge - and remember, we care....š"
Ok, maybe not so sarcastic as that, but what I bitterly dislike about this entire fiasco is that I spent months and months with these problems, with a phone that was effectively non-operational, wasting my time, troubleshooting, listening to crackpot BS theories, solutions and the 'Apple can do no wrong' worshippers blaming users on their usage habits, with no acknowledgement - nothing but silence from the people in the big apple that knew about this and did nothing to explain the deliberate throttling until just recently, culminating in an almost unheard of apology.š®
So now, lets wait for the 'fix'. If people will be given the choice to disable the feature if desired - great - if they don't like it they can always vote with their wallets and that will be their choice too. The condescending 'we know what's best for the plebs' attitude will always backfire in the end.