Logic Pro X found audio files in 8 bit format

Every time a open my project the alert pops out:

"Logic Pro X found 8 audio files in 8 bit format. / This format is unsupported and cannot be played back."


Some of the regions that were fine previously stopped playing and I've lost the tracks that I recorded on Saturday.


After recording I bounced a project to send my friend a rough mix, but when I got home and checked it on different speakers, I decided to tweak it a bit. That's when I noticed some of the files were gone. How could this happen?


I've located corrupted audio files on my disk and the couldn't be played with iTunes.


Logic Pro X: 10.3.3

Macbook 15 inch with touch bar and Touch ID on High Sierra: 10.13.2

FileVault was turned on – I turned it off since.


P.S. Maybe there was a software update in between bouncing and me reopening the project.

MacBook Pro TouchBar and Touch ID, macOS High Sierra (10.13.2), Logic Pro X: 10.3.3

Posted on Dec 18, 2017 11:37 PM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Feb 21, 2018 2:30 PM

It seems indeed that the problem was due to the audio files being stored on a FAT32 drive. After moving them to an HFS one, the problem no longer occurred. I haven't been able to recover the corrupted files, though (e.g. using raw format import & changing file header).


This is truly irritating, since you would think that once you stop recording a take, any DAW should leave the recorderd audio files alone and (unless you deliberately utilize any destructive editing) perform read out operations at best. Contrary to that, Logic actually seems to change data in the files upon project shutdown. I can't think of any logic behind this (talk about logic in Logic, what a pun), let alone why this should lead to (randomly!!) corrupted files on FAT32 drives after re-opeing the project.


I've recorde to external drives dozens of times with Logic and no problem whatsoever, but I'm not exactly positive that they were all HFS. Following the reasoning above, they must have been...?!


Anyway - to be safe, no more recording to FAT32 for me.

One complete day of a paid recording session gone to h*e*l*l, with an appropriate damage to my personal reputation...
Whoever may be responsible for this, THANK YOU VERY MUCH.


@Rainburst: Using Logic 10.2.4



PS. Interesting censorship detail: I previously wrote the word *h*e*l*l* (without these asterisks) in this post, and after posting, some algorithm obviously censored the word, leaving it as all asterisks... - come on Apple, that's ridiculous, it's not even a cuss word.

26 replies

Dec 21, 2017 5:33 AM in response to Pancenter

Thanks, Pancenter. I have checked the disk for errors and none were found. I used Soundhack app to restore the audio file header and it partially worked. I've managed to make the file playable again but I couldn't figure out a way to remove the digital noise. Looks like the data is still intact, but the capabilities of sound hack does not cover the particular format.

Jan 3, 2018 1:44 PM in response to Pancenter

Actually I've listened to the files you've recovered on several devices - it is not distortion, it's the background noise. Like white or pink. It's similar to what you'll get by cranking up mic preamp level. I've checked again on my Windows laptop - it's definitely present. The recording was digital in nature - it was done through kemper - so there was absolutely no noise.


The problem on my mac may be hardware fault, but this is not an argument in support of this theory.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Logic Pro X found audio files in 8 bit format

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.