People seem to have selective reading and/or listening. At no time did Apple (as far as I can find anywhere) say iPad Pro is a laptop replacement.
Really? Did you bother to watch Apple's own keynote for the 2018 iPad Pro?
They did say, it is as powerful as a laptop (it is). They did it is as fast (in many cases faster) than a laptop (it is). They said the resolution of the display exceeds the resolution of most laptops (it does). They never said it is a laptop or provide all the functionality of a laptop.
Oh, okay, you did watch the keynote. You simply parsed the bits that support your argument that iPad doesn't require a mouse, or, that Apple didn't compare the iPad to a notebook, or that the iPad can replace a notebook?
Or should I focus simply on what Apple doesn't say vs. what they do?
*SIGH*
It's perfectly reasonable to assume that everyone posting here has been around long enough to understand that the iPad has been replacing notebooks ever since it was introduced back in 2010. For those who use a notebook for web, email and even a few work apps, an iPad can easily support those needs. I don't think anyone that's posted in this thread denies this?
Even so, it would seem that many require that Apple's iOS for iPad support mouse input. Whether it's for spreadsheets (Excel), print media content creation, or even design, some users have been asking for this feature support for years. assuming a negative position versus an affirmative one on this one, specific feature request, it seems as if Apple is simply asking their customers to do without? How does adding mouse support diminish iOS or iPad considering that Apple has already added Apple Pencil and the software support necessary for stylus input while at the same time seeming to ignore the requests of countless customers who have requested mouse support on iPad? I simply don't see Apple Pencil and mouse support as mutually exclusive to one another?
That's the real shame of this entire topic: Apple could have added this feature years ago. The first generation iPad Pro was launched alongside the Apple Pencil, which was only supported (initially) by the iPad Pro. Apple designed both a new screen for the Pad Pro that supported stylus input, AND an entirely new Apple Pencil, which was Apple's first attempt at a stylus in nearly 20 years. And, it was so successful they've recently released its replacement (sibling?), the Apple Pencil 2.
I mentioned the Apple Pencil because iPad Pro owners are finding more uses for their iPad Pros and wondering aloud "If Apple can make an entirely new product specifically for iPad, it shouldn't be difficult to add support for a mouse?" I've paraphrased several threads from both here and on several Apple fan forums that are intensely pro-Apple. These aren't the voices of those who have some unreasonable distaste for Apple. Apple iPad owners are asking for this feature so they can try to use their iPad's more and their notebooks less. This feature request actually supports Apple's narrative that the new iPad Pro can take the place of the notebooks they use daily.
I can recall the emerging feature requests for a stylus days after the release of the first iPad. (Seriously: https://discussions.apple.com/thread/2395385) But Steve Jobs infamously asked "Who want's a stylus?" and we know the rest of the story (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4YY3MSaUqMg) Hint: Apple Pencil, both the original and 2nd gen, has been a resounding success for Apple. It saw sales double in year-to-year sales from 2017 to 2018.
Could mouse support affect iPad sales? I'm not completely sure, but seriously, how could it hurt? This could even become an opportunity for Apple, by announcing mouse support for iOS alongside something like Adobe Photoshop for iOS or even iOS's upcoming "Dark Mode" support in iOS 13. At the very least Apple Mouse sales could spike, as Apple is now offering Space Grey options for both Apple Mouse and Smart Keyboard.
Sorry for length, got a bit ahead of myself! In summary, I just don't understand how those who defend Apple by suggesting there's nothing to this mouse support issue and we should all just move along. After nearly a decade of asking for it, perhaps Apple will surprise us soon?
Even so, I'm not holding my breath 😑