Archiving Time Machine backup to a Synology NAS

Hi everyone


I have used Time Machine for years and have backups on an external USB drive. I've just installed a Synology NAS and I've successfully configured that to be the destination for Time Machine. The external USB drive is no longer needed to back up my Mac, but it is a bit of an archive which I would like to preserve, but on the Synology NAS (so I can re-use the USB drive!). Obviously I want to use a different shared folder on the NAS from the Time Machine backup folder so those don't get in each other's way.


I've tried to copy the contents of the USB drive to the NAS, but that doesn't work: I get an error message that the destination drive is the wrong format. Help! How do I configure the Synology folder so it can accept the Time Machine data?


Any help greatly appreciated!


Jan-Peter

IMAC (RETINA 5K, 27-INCH, LATE 2015), macOS High Sierra (10.13.6), Time Machine, Synology NAS

Posted on Aug 9, 2018 6:10 AM

Reply

Similar questions

6 replies

Aug 9, 2018 6:59 AM in response to Jan-Peter Onstwedder

I don't believe this is going to be possible.


The Synology is a network file server aka NAS and such devices store Time Machine backups inside a 'sparse bundle disk image'. Local backups like your USB drive are stored directly as files on the backup drive.


It is possible to move backups from one local drive to another, and it might be possible to move a network Time Machine backup from one server to another but I cannot see a realistic way to convert from one format of Time Machine backup to another.

Aug 10, 2018 2:01 AM in response to Jan-Peter Onstwedder

As I mentioned local drives i.e. USB use a different format for Time Machine to network servers e.g. Synology. Local drives use Apple's HFS+ format - they will not even work with Apple's newer APFS disk format.


Time Machine relies on a HFS+ specific feature which is to create 'hard links' between copies of the files, this allows a single copy to be present in each generation of the Time Machine backup and not take up additional storage each time.


Apple get round the fact network servers do not use HFS+ by creating a 'sparse bundle disk image' and the disk image acts as a virtual HFS+ formatted drive.


You could in theory either manually create or re-use an existing sparse bindle disk image and 'copy' the contents of the USB drive in to it. In reality this as far as I know has never been done, is likely to have problems due to the complex way Time Machine works and take an extraordinarily long time - with no guarantee it would work. Assuming it did work you could then 'mount' the image and manually tell Time Machine to 'browse' this non-standard location.


You could try simplifying this by making a disk image back of the USB drive.

Aug 9, 2018 7:21 AM in response to Jan-Peter Onstwedder

Backing-up your backups:


It’s generally not a good idea to copy or back-up your backups. If there’s a problem on your primary backups, it will be copied to (and perhaps magnified on) the secondary ones.

If your backups are on a Time Capsule, you can "archive" them to a USB drive connected to the Time Capsule. See How do I back-up my Time Capsule and/or Air Disk? As you’ll see, there are some downsides, however, so that's probably not a good strategy.

from this article by the late James Pond, in which he discusses way to proceed when you want to backup your backups:

.Pondini's Time Machine - Frequently Asked Questions -- 27. Can I have "dual" backups? Or back up my Backups?


.

Aug 10, 2018 1:44 AM in response to Grant Bennet-Alder

I get that but that's not really what I am trying to do. I could use save my old USB backup disk, and if I ever wanted to restore a file that's on that backup but no longer on the new backup, I'd just connect that USB disk and have Time Machine restore the file. that's easy. But I want to re-use the USB disk, and thought I could copy the contents to a NAS (different folder/drive from the new backup disk). If I wanted to restore a file, I'd copy it back to a USB drive, connect that and use Time Machine to restore the file(s). But I guess Time Machine's deep dependancy on the Apple disk format makes that impractical?


It's another example for me where these 'clever' solutions like compression schemes, different file systems etc. make things less flexible. I might just go back to a backup system of copying files, and no longer using Time Machine. It feels too fragile!


Thanks for everyone's help.


Jan-Peter

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Archiving Time Machine backup to a Synology NAS

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.