Ditto. I'm an active septuagenarian and have had fall detection on since I installed the watch (on release day). I've had multiple fall alerts that didn't seem appropriate. Although, strangely enough, golf doesn't seem to trigger an alert, I've had it trigger using a hammer in the off hand, trigger when pushing a garden stake into the ground, trigger pull-starting a mower. Fall detection seems like a terrific idea (my doctor asks me every 6 months about falling), but it seems to have problems in implementation. First, there's no way to cancel the alert hands-free. "Hey Siri, I haven't fallen." would be a nice feature. With any ambient noise or activity in the vicinity, the alert isn't noticeable enough (except the "I'm about to call 911" feature which lights up the accompanying iPhone). There's no clue that it's learning anything - about my activity or my "I didn't fall" cancellations. The Series 4 even seems a bit less sensitive in bedside clock mode (bump it to see the time) than my Series 2 that preceded it, so why then is it so sensitive in fall detection mode? Can I adjust its sensitivity?
I'm not the human physiology expert, but it seems reasonable that a "fall" would require a couple things - some sudden motion of the type found in a fall, termination of that motion abruptly, validation that this motion happened while the watch was on your wrist, and validation that I'm in a fallen position (prone, supine, etc.). The watch seems to know when I'm standing (or not)... can't it do better to determine whether I'm horizontal or not?
I'm not knocking fall detection. I'd just like to be able to use it with fewer (all, so far) false triggers. Seriously... "Hey Siri, I didn't fall."