Apple Event: May 7th at 7 am PT

Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Crackling sound on MacBook Pro 2018

I have the new MacBook Pro 2018 15' I've had it for almost two moths now. I'm sure some user are familiar with the crackling sound from the speakers on their new MacBook Pro. Even apple has addressed this with the macOS High Sierra 10.13. 6 supplemental Update 2.


However, even after updating I still have a crackling sound or a random sounds every time my speakers gets on 44 100 Hz. I can easily fix it with selecting 48 000 Hz, but I still find it shocking that the MacBook 2018 can't use 44 100 Hz... I don't want my Mac on service either atm, simply cause I still believe Apple has a fix for it. I've already replaced my MacBook Pro 2018 15' model once so I don't believe it will help if I try again. (I got it replaced for the same problem). The only reason this is bothering me is simple cause I work with sound, music to be exact.


So I'm just curious if people still have a problem with their MacBook's using 44 100 Hz? or if its just mine.

MacBook Pro (15-inch, 2018), macOS High Sierra (10.13.6)

Posted on Oct 9, 2018 3:18 PM

Reply
Question marked as Best reply

Posted on Dec 11, 2018 11:21 AM

I went round and round with Apple Support a few months back regarding this issue, and eventually it seemed that the problem went away with my initial Mojave upgrade.


However, in recent weeks, and especially with the release of 10.14.2, the crackling and popping has come back more frequently.

I think we need to resurface attention to this issue, as there is something seriously wrong with this 2018 round of MBP's.


Awaiting further developments...


53 replies

Jan 12, 2019 3:31 PM in response to Alias98

So, I just bought the MacBook Pro 2018 - 13 inch. The second day I turned it on, it wouldn't turn on- it said there were installation issues. An hour later on the phone with Apple, we got it up and running again, but there was the crackling speaker issue! I thought I had gotten a lemon, so I exchanged it. This second computer started up with the crackling sounds, and the Apple care person (none have them have EVER heard of this issue, by the way) took me through one restart that made the computer's entire sound system disappear- it didn't recognize its own speakers or microphones. It's working now, but I might just return this, and wait until Apple has figured this issue out. I do a lot of recording work, and bought this to make my work go more smoothly, which will not be the case with an unreliable sound system.

Jan 15, 2019 10:46 AM in response to PeterScu

I have just finished a call with tech support representative and we agreed to run some tests... I will try to do more testing because I don't use macbook pro all day everyday . I have also bought it to use for making music as I am a music producer.

what type of crackling you have , PeterScu? I've connected my audio interface today and got a strange cut offs/popups during vocal recording in Cubase so I will have to run more of these tests too.

But as for crackling I'm gonna investigate it and help Apple tech support to learn about the issue. feels like they have a great tech support

Jan 19, 2019 8:37 PM in response to Alias98

I have the same issues with the static now. l have fixed all the problems after I migrated from my older Macbook pro. It gave me a lot of issues with some software incompatibility. Very frustrating to figure out. Reformat my drive twice, then uninstall some older and update all the software.

Now come in this issue with the speakers. I don't play a lot of music on my new mac. When I start listening to Youtube channel and I noticed the speaker quality is very bad. I started to Google the issue with the static and crackling. Some of the fix was installing new OS updated. Which is not my case since my Macbook is the latest up-to-date version. I'm planning to bring my Macbook to the store to see if it is the speakers defeated.

Jan 20, 2019 11:25 AM in response to BenvelBen

I wonder (but don’t know if it’s possible to find out) what’s the actual rate of occurrence for the crackling sound issue, supposing someone buys a MacBook Pro 2018 and ensures he or she runs Mojave, issue appearing regardless of app used and regardless of using internal or external speakers/headphones.


(I don’t find it reported much in reviews but a lot of people do complain here & at Apple stores so I would be curious on some stats...)


Context: For now I have a MacBook Pro early 2015, so I’m glad I “passed” the butterfly keyboard issues of 2016-17, but only to find out here that 2018 might have an ugly issue too (for somebody who often listens to music on the computer, like I do while working.)


Should I really try to stick with 2015 as much as possible as such issues seem to keep appearning? :-/

Feb 27, 2019 2:58 AM in response to Alias98

Hi, everyone - is there really still no official solution for this problem?


I bought a MBP 15" in January and have the same cracking speaker problem as discribed in this thread.

If I use an external soundscard (RME UC), the problem manifests though dropouts and not the cracking sound. But it never the less makes the MBP useless for any audio purpose.


Can't really get a good overview if it really helps to upgrade to Mojave. Can someone that did this and tested it for a couple of weeks, please confirm that it actually works?


I'm running 10.13.6.


Cheers




Mar 12, 2019 4:38 PM in response to Alias98

I've timed how long it takes after I start listening to music before the crackling starts and it's right at ±50 minutes. Moreover, the sound )music and speech) becomes momentarily garbled at that point so I'm wondering if this isn't a 'buffering' problem in the software. The buffer becomes overfilled and 'spits back'. I just changed over to 48,000 Hz and am interested to see if that helps, as has been suggested by some.

Mar 12, 2019 7:56 PM in response to dennisfromleucadia

Interesting. I found exactly the same behavior. It starts like clockwork right around 50 minutes. I also experience garbled audio, and it gets worse if you play more than one source at the same time.


I spent a few months trying to get Apple support to fix the issue. They've done nothing. So in the last phone call I asked for Executive Customer Service. (They don't connect you via phone, you have to write a letter and send a fax.) Anyway, in the call I asked them how technical issues are ranked by support.


The Customer Relations agent explained how Apple's entire internal system for technical issues works. This is what he told me, (and what he strongly recommends is the only way to get this issue looked into ASAP.)


Apple addresses technical issues by rank. The ranking is determined by voting on issues. He told me this issue has TWO votes. (Yes, you read that right. two votes only.)


He also said that support has no means to escalate or vote on an issue. Support is forced to accept Engineering's instructions. Customer Relations also have no power to escalate or vote on issues.


(This next bit comes from an article I'll link at the bottom where an ex-Apple engineer explained the issue.) Ironically, Engineering cannot address issues unless they are assigned to them by Project Managers. So even if a software engineer wanted to fix the issue, Apple's corporate structure prevents them from being able to do

anything. All prioritization happens by the project managers that oversee the software engineers. Even worse, project managers can override decisions made by Software engineers.


Anyway... I asked him if what i see reported in these threads are true than how is it possible that the Apple Store has been replacing machines but the issue hasn't been considered a priority for voting...


He threw a few scenarios at me, and stated that he has no way to confirm if the scenarios are part of the issue... That said it does explain the why I keep seeing different threads where people report they're on their 2nd or 3rd machine with the same issue...


Scenario:

People are most likely returning the machines instead of phoning support to report and document the issue. Since the store has no way to address the issue, all they can do is replace it. Although the store is supposed to be thorough in what they document about the replacement, there's nothing that prevents the employee from just writing something like "sound is broken", or "speakers sound blown", etc... If the employee handling the replacement isn't familiar with the issue it's very likely they don't write much more than that..


He recommended I post the following in threads about the issue:


A. He does think the issue is most likely software-based.


B. If people are going to have their machine replaced, they should phone support first and report a detailed description of the issue with video documenting the behavior. Replacement can still be done after the fact..


C. Just bringing the machine into the Apple Store increases the likelihood that the person replacing the machine doesn't provide enough information to correlate the replacement with the issue.


D. Getting the issue resoved is unfortunately going to require en effort from people experiencing the issue. The short version is... Because of how Apple's voting system prevents anyone outside of project management to escalate an issue, the only way the issue's going to generate enough concern ASAP is by as many people logging the issue with support, sending as much documentation as possible before replacing it.


E. Submit video, and/or screen recordings of the behavior before replacing the machine.


F. He encouraged people to submit letters to Tim Cook's office. This is the only office that has the ability to prioritize an issue down the chain to Engineering.


G. If you decide to contact Tim Cook's office you'll want detailed documentation anyway. If you have no video and/or documentation proving the issue they have nothing to work with. (Also, realize Cook's office is constantly fielding issues users feel are priority... If they're going to explore the issue your case needs to be compelling...)


That's the unpleasant reality of the situation :(

We're basically stuck having to report to support. Support will most likely shoot the issue down. Ultimately the only thing that's going to expedite the process is to accept you're going to have to reach out to Tim Cook's office and have a documented case...


Wish I had better news, but after chasing this issue down for 4 months now I've exhausted every option and indeed am in the process of drafting a letter/fax/email I'm submitting to his office.


Article mentioned above:

https://bgr.com/2018/02/13/ios-new-features-developer-apple-software/

Mar 13, 2019 4:46 PM in response to zeddsdeadbaby

As I posted yesterday with regard to the irritating intermittent buzzing, crackling sound, I followed the advice of one responder and used the Audio MIDI Setup app to change the format for the MacBook Pro speakers from 44,100 Hz to 48,000Hz and have been listening to music all day now with no buzzing or crackling. That seems to resolve the problem. Maybe that info should be passed along to the support folks. It's really a simple fix.

Mar 15, 2019 5:07 PM in response to koralee806

I also do alot of recordeing work and was putting off the mojave update . finally did it. Have 10.14.3 and the crackle sound is constant in headphones regardless of the source if the audio. Daw. Safari . files . dont matter. And no trouble shoot options now work not restarting not reinstalling... Nothing And its on 2 different macs I own . this is awful

Mar 15, 2019 5:47 PM in response to dennisfromleucadia

Glad this is working for you. Using Audio MIDI set to 48k is fine for general music listening in iTunes... The problem is that some of us work in Logic, Live, Pro Tools or various other DAWs where we use different sample rates, and setting a sample rate in a DAW changes the Sample Rate settings in Audio MIDI Setup... 48k's is used mostly for video editing and film scores, 44.1, 88.2 and 96k are mostly used for audio, depending on the musician or engineers preferences. (That isn't to say some don't use 48k, but most of the time it's one of the other 3...)

Mar 18, 2019 8:41 AM in response to zeddsdeadbaby

On December 1, 2018 I bought a brand new MacBook Pro Quad Core with Touch Bar. The crackling sound happens when I play iTunes. It really ****** me off! I updated to Mojave but the crackling persists. If you bring your laptop to the store they'll just give you another laptop that has the same problem. It appears Apple knows about this issue as it has been going on for a while now. It would have been fixed by now if Steve Jobs was still alive but he isn't and we are stuck with the present day Apple that isn't as concerned. It's "our" problem, not theirs.

Mar 18, 2019 9:33 AM in response to RockBands

"If you bring your laptop to the store they'll just give you another laptop that has the same problem."


I have to disagree with that wholeheartedly. You're suggesting that every single 2018 MBP has this problem. They don't. I've never experienced any crackling sounds. I play music and watch YouTube music videos on it constantly.

Crackling sound on MacBook Pro 2018

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.