I thought I'd note my experiences. Partly because it infuriates me to hear/see so many people resorting to just binning and replacing Apple hardware because of issues that Apple should take responsibility for. I have no legal experience, but I read enough of Martin Lewis's moneysavingexpert.com to have a reasonable grasp on my consumer rights. Unfortunately this probably doesn't help anyone outside the UK.
Jul '08 iPhone 3G original replaced due to cosmetic issues in Dec '08.
After updating to f/w 3.1.2 (Oct '09) I noticed the phone dropping off my home wifi onto 3G ([un]fortunately it's only about 20% slower than my broadband!). At times it would prompt to reconnect to various SIDs (sometimes listing mine). At times it would prompt for the passkey for my SID and a few minutes later (after not providing the passkey) I would find it connected back to my SID.
The same would happen at work (a little more complicated as work WiFi is not passkey based).
I booked in for a 'Genius' appointment at Apple Store Regent St. in Nov '09
Whilst waiting, it dropped off the Apple Store wifi(!)
Upon explaining the issue the 'Genius' first asked if I'd done a restore- yes I had. He then decided it must be hardware and checked the warranty on the phone and advised as it was expired they would not be able to help. I explained that under the UK's Sale of Goods Act 1979, goods can be expected to last a reasonable length of time. Given that this particular handset was less than 12 months old, it would be reasonable for this handset to still be operational.
The 'Genius' advised that he couldn't really comment on legal points, but if it went down that avenue I would probably have to prove in court that it was a network (i.e. WiFi) issue. 😉 I explained that given the iPhone was a consumer product with a closed operating system this would be very difficult to do and that with 20 years of Unix support I would only be able to diagnose the issue with the phone JailBroken. This situation would be likely to come under the UK's Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977.
A little bit of empathy for him, I said that I appreciated that he was following Apple's processes and procedures but that as the phone was sold in the UK, then those processes must follow UK law and it should not be a matter of course for a consumer to take a matter to court just to have UK law upheld.
Again he couldn't really comment on legal points, offered a Manager who tried to have me repeat the whole conversation again (something that I consider a pet-peeve when being passed between staff in customer service situations). He said that the length of time the product can be expect to last is something that would have to be decided by a Court of Law, however they were prepared to offer a replacement as a gesture of goodwill, but on the condition that the replacement would only carry a 90-day warranty. Clearly they weren't agreeing or listening to my complete lack of interest in their 'warranties'.
I really don't believe this is/was a hardware issue, but since the 'Genius' couldn't/wouldn't blame the firmware then what choice did I have;-)
The replacement phone behaved in the same way, so last week, well within the 90-day warranty I took it to another Apple Store where I was told it was more likely to be a WiFi issue than a faulty phone. I suggested that I would politely disagree with him.
#1 with 50 million units produced if there was a fault on one unit, it's reasonable to expect it could be a manufacturing or component issue that would affect other units, working for a computer company this is the sort of this that we see regularly, there are few 'random' faults.
#2 he continued to blame the WiFi when I mentioned home, work and AppleStore networks all behaved the same, so we have a closed operating system on the phone, and 3 different wireless networks, one of which is provided by the OS vendor, and we're trying to blame the WiFi?
He checked for water damage (no joy).
I also had a issue with the iPhone power button which had become lopsided, given how critical the two buttons are to using the phone I really didn't want to wait for this to develop further after the 90-day toy-town warranty had expired!
So I have another replacement iPhone, we'll see if they update 3.1.2 again in the next 90 days...at this rate I'll be getting another replacement handset in time for selling on ebay just before the next handset arrives...