damage to macbook pro logic board from battery that has swollen

Not sure if this is the place for advice at this level of technicality but I am trying to get a 2011 MBP to work after the battery had swollen ALMOST to the point of breaking the trackpad. I have replaced trackpads before, even to the level of having an ally MBP with a white A1342 panel!


With this one however, the unit works fine with no battery but when I insert a new battery in it, the unit bongs and then dies completely immediately I plug the battery plug in! I can turn the unit over and restart but it gets as far as the apple and then dies within a half a second or so. With the unit off, the magsafe light doesnt go from green to orange.


I thought the battery must have a short in it overriding even the on/off switch but have replaced the battery with another one that gives the same result

Posted on Feb 28, 2019 12:36 PM

Reply

Similar questions

8 replies

Mar 1, 2019 7:59 AM in response to DManzaluni

the unit works fine with no battery but when I insert a new battery in it, the unit bongs and then dies completely immediately I plug the battery plug in!

Yes, obviously I tried those resets before I asked circuit board level technical questions here


The swollen battery has done damage to the board beyond what can be resolved in a technical support forum here.


It is impossible to predict the resolve, except to take it in for assessment/repair/replacement of the logic board(?) and your way forward.


The controller(2) on the board are not recognizing and responding to the the DC-in from the power adapter voltage output which are unregulated — it is the circuitry inside the Mac that both conditions and regulate the input making changes to the monitoring feedback ie charging/ green-amber light /icon in the menubar etc


Notebook computer   use the installed battery to buffer against voltage fluctuations by relying on the normal battery. It is not advisable to use your notebook computer without a normal working battery in good condition. You are at risk having the  voltage fluctuation damaging further the internal components.


In or out of warranty you can get a free over the counter 'Apple Service Diagnostics' test.

Make an appointment

https://www.apple.com/retail/geniusbar/


Apple most likely will decline to do the work, on a 2011 MBP—but you will have the diagnosis.

Vintage and obsolete products - Apple Support



Any independent and reliable computer repair shop would do the job for you if you are not up to the task yourself.


Mar 1, 2019 6:00 PM in response to DManzaluni

You should go to his YouTube site and try to contact him.


Or go to the iFixit site and see if someone there has worked through this.


And then look around for a reputable 3rd party repair site in your area that has diagnostic tools, a good desk board microscope and can do board level soldering. They would probably be able to help you locate the damage on your logic board and do the solder/chip replacement if necessary.

Mar 3, 2019 3:57 PM in response to leroydouglas

I agree with you but the Genius Bar doesn't! They say firstly that if the battery isnt present, their diagnostics will note that and then stop immediately. they wouldn't even run it with no battery.


Plus, if the unit works with no battery but dies immediately the battery is plugged in, they insist there must be something wrong with the battery plain and simple!


When I said this was the second battery that had given the same problem and mightn't this mean there ISN'T a problem with the battery? They said that with a third party battery, no.

Mar 3, 2019 4:29 PM in response to DManzaluni

2011 MacBook Pro already can't run the latest version of MacOS, although High Sierra that it can run is still getting security updates for now.


How much more money do you want to pour into this older computer, when it is behaving so badly?


I am the last guy to want the Hardware to win. It makes me crazy when the computers win.


But wouldn't you be better off putting your money toward a computer that is closer to meeting your current needs and saying goodbye to this one?

Mar 3, 2019 8:35 PM in response to Grant Bennet-Alder

Don't I know it!


I spent a fortune on a new Macbook Pro, only to find that as Apple can't produce a suitable palm rejection driver that other manufacturers somehow managed in 2001, I cant use it for anything as sophisticated as basic word processing! And don't get me started on how Apple believes Moore's Law doesn't apply to their computers.


Touchbar is cute though.


So I have to use the one with the properly thought-out trackpad. Not the one where the trackpad gets in the way of any use of the keyboard!


Plus it doesnt help that I have had to make a half dozen trips down to the Apple Store with it. It's there at the moment, getting its second or third keyboard. Still, it is nice that Apple now admit that there might be a problem with these computers. At first they didnt!

Mar 1, 2019 9:06 AM in response to leroydouglas

Thanks for that reply but will the apple diagnostics which they do say anything other than what we already know, that there is a problem with the logic board? Isn't shlepping along to some apple store, only to be told this by a non-specific diagnostic test, - by a genius who only deals with new or under warranty computers, - a bit of a wild goose chase?


Does that guy (who puts out those excruciatingly long YouTube videos showing how he knows more than apple about these things) frequent this forum? Someone like that should have seen this problem numerous times before and know whether it is possible to fix or reset it? He usually manages to get to the nub of his computer's problem around minute 57, he might recognise my symptoms, which have now morphed into:


When you press the on switch, the light on the front edge to the right now flashes 6 times before nothing happens

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

damage to macbook pro logic board from battery that has swollen

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.