Hello,
I hope this thread is still being read by a few people even in these crazy times. I would like to thank every poster who was able to stick to the issue.
I have had my new iPhone 11 Pro for two weeks now and am by now convinced that what bugs me with my iPhone 11 Pro is a software issue. On top of that, the wide angle lens is bad but for hardware reasons. I have very much looked forward to the wide angle lens but in its current state it’s worse than a bad panoramic shot cropped afterwards.
I would like to describe an effect which caught my eye on the first few pictures that I took with this camera and which seem to have to do with some kind of filter action that the iPhone applies to the image. If there is very fine detail in the image, whether it is letters from a newspaper page or blossoms on a tree a couple of yards away, it will over-enhance the edges almost as though I was treating the image with that dreamy google software. It seems as though this software has the goal to make the image as such look good on the iPhone screen or any other small screen, which I could understand as a objective because many people post the images that they made with their iPhones to Apps on small screens. So maybe this is equivalent to musicians optimizing the sound for their music to bad speakers on MP3 - Horrible quality but sounds good on on bad speakers or headsets.
I also have the impression that the pictures that I took with my iPhone 6s and 6S plus are more “true” to the surface of or texture of the scene. As far as filter functions go, I think it’s awesome how the filter which is being employed on the 11 pro optimizes the image for inspection on a small screen, however I really don’t like what this filter does to the texture of things... somewhere in this thread someone mentioned it looks as though someone took a grass brush to the texture of the grass. I agree. I am seriously reminded of that Google software which is supposed to bring forth animal faces in random scenes. Someone else mentioned that he was told in the Apple Store that this is supposed to be reminiscent of the grain that one would get from analog film material. I beg to differ, I remember what that looked like, not like that.
I tried to deactivate all options of enhancement in the camera app as well as in the photo app but there is one issue that I can’t seem to get rid of, and that is this automatic contrast enhancing effect that seems to happen to the image right after you open the photo app and look at the image that you just took. If you are interested in duplicating this effect, just take a picture of a newspaper page like The NY Times, say, from straight above as though you wanted to reproduce it and see what happens, and if you have an older iPhone flying around, try the same thing with that and compare the effects. I wonder if it might be what Apple calls the spreading of the image dynamic range over the entire dynamic range of the display. However, that doesn’t explain the edge-filter style effect that I observe with fine details - it’s almost as though the iPhone was trying to overdo it with edges or fine structures in general to create an impression of a focused scene via software. An image which looks sharp but isn’t.
I am pretty sure that Apple uses a different filter function for the treatment of the textures in the image than they used before, on the previous models. Sadly my previous models were 6s and 6s plus, But what I read on this thread here, other people seem to have preferred their previous cameras’ performance as well. I personally don’t like it, because it seems to over-optimize for small screens and sacrifice a lot of the actually existing image resolution for that goal.. It looks good when you look at it on the iPhone screen but when you zoom into it it’s quite horrible.
Here’s a question: is there any way how one can deactivate the edge-enhancing effect? The Auto-enhancement that happens right away?
On a side note: I bought this iPhone because I had read an article by a photographer who had taken this unit (iPhone 11 pro) out into the Scottish highlands, and he made truly magnificent photos, and he was also quite smitten with the device, however he had been using the ProCamera app as well. I also can report that some of the more intrusive effects that the Apple app (I haven’t decided yet if it’s the photo app or the Camera app) seem to be absent when using the Pro Camera app, but my research into this topic isn’t concluded yet.
All in all I think Apple has gone too far with the software enhancement and filtering. But I have been able to take great pictures already, and maybe at some point in time I will get used to the swirly texture when you zoom in to the image. I’m not quite there yet though.
I wish everybody all the best in these crazy Corona times. If anybody has a helpful advice on my misgivings, I would be very grateful. Take care.