OS Catalina. 2 MAC HD data drives

After installing Catalina a second time, it put a second Mac HD data partition. Then when trying to use Time Machine, it failed. Because there are two drives with the same name HD data. How do I rename the drive or delete the Drive. How do I know which one Catalina is using?

iMac Line (2012 and Later)

Posted on Oct 11, 2019 4:26 PM

Reply
47 replies

Dec 20, 2019 5:01 AM in response to Rayamc

I just had this happen to me after I had problems with an update in Catalina which caused it not to boot up, so I had to erase all my data and do full reinstall of Cataline then a full data restore from Time Machine.

Apple Support guided me through the process.

  1. Back up the system on Time Machine (Full back up or do a new incremental before starting)
  2. Remove/unplug any devices (including Time Machine connections) and any other external drives.
  3. Reboot Machine and ensure only Finder is running.
  4. Open Disk Utility
  5. One of the Macintosh HD - Data will have the Home icon, one will not, it will also be the one with the lowest usage used about 1mb/2mb.
  6. Select that and use the - (minus) key at the top, this will remove the Partition/Disk Image (Note: Erase will not do the job as this will just remove the data on the drive), you will be prompted to remove it. Confirm it.
  7. Reboot again.
  8. Check to ensure the new HD Data, now correctly shows the Free Space and Used Spaced which when added together match the max capacity of the volume (unless you have other partitiions defined).
  9. Plug in again all external devices - Time Machine drive etc.
  10. Do another backup / incremental after.


Nov 20, 2019 8:27 AM in response to craig150

I deleted both the Data drives, leaving the HD drive in place. Shut down and restarted in Recovery mode and tried to use Time Machine to recover. It found Time Machine but would not start the download. Then tried to Reinstall Mac OS onto Mac HD. Got the message "The target volume is part of an incomplete system and cannot be installed to".

HELP please

Dec 2, 2019 6:41 AM in response to craig150

Craig150,

I hardly think this issue is solved.


The worst part of this experience for me is that Time Machine was horribly corrupted during the process of restoration or, did not import and parse the data properly. I did end up renaming a data drive to move forward but everything after that was a domino effect of failures.


The double Data drive images caused Time Machine to fail until a drive was renamed.


How is one to know which drive is legitimately connected to the installation and going to function properly? I have moved on and just left things alone as I have spent so much time with this upgrade issue on so many levels that I need to get work done instead of bang my head against the Apple wall. I can only hope Time Machine is functioning properly, I no longer trust the process.


At some point down the road I will wipe everything and start fresh, probably after a few iterations of upgrades, but this has been a ridiculous exercise in Apple dramatically changing the game with no sensible path for educating end users in place.


Very frustrating,

gchdrake

Dec 2, 2019 7:51 AM in response to vincentfromprt

I would only use the last back up; the back up that only contains one drive. However, you can use the finder to change the name of one of the HD data drives. Allowing time machine to back up. This only changes the name that YOU see. Not the name that Catalina is actually using for its HD data.


of course, the risk is: you are copying the same problem and inserting it after you have cleaned everything up. Especially, if you look at the HD data drive and it has already created a new container and or volume.


do you not have a good back up before the problem started?

copying the problem, will most likely create another problem.

Dec 2, 2019 8:03 AM in response to gchdrake

Apple has confirmed, that renaming the drive just exacerbates problems.

basically, starting fresh, with an old back up, which was known to be good is useful.


to answer one of your questions: you can look up the time and date in finder through GET info, about when the drive was created.


The main reason, I had to start over was: each data drive had created another volume and container, which doubled the memory usage. The easiest way is to remove everything off the computer, via the steps, and then repair with the backup before the problems. My iMac is working great and fast as advertised in Catalina.






This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

OS Catalina. 2 MAC HD data drives

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.