fred_logan wrote:
Yes, exactly. Macbook Pro (15 inch, 16GB RAM, 2017).
What version of Big Sur are you running? There was an issue with battery charging on a few models, as I recall, that was corrected in one of the Big Sur updates, a few updates ago.
So. Are you actually claiming that you fully wiped your drive before installing a pristine (more recent) version of Big Sur, without any installation or restoration of any software that doesn’t come with the Big Sur installation—including no third-party software drivers for third-party add-on hardware (such are often downloaded, installed, and run without user involvement)?
That would be quite extraordinary!
Such has never failed! Such is the most tested configuration of macOS (for all versions)!
If you are actually making this claim, then this would suggest you have a problem with your hardware!
However. Maybe an SMC and/or NVRAM reset—on your truly clean Big Sur install—may help correct some firmware issue that is “masquerading” as a “hardware” problem.
I wonder how long it will take Apple to solve this issue as this thread is open since November 2020.
So long as there are no cases where a truly clean Big Sur install fails on well running and well configured hardware (remember, this is the most tested configuration of all), there is nothing Apple can do «to solve this issue», since there is no issue with Big Sur on the hardware Apple has deemed compatible.
So, a downgrade to Catalina is the only option that REALLY works so far?
If you actually have a problem with a truly clean Big Sur install, that cannot be corrected with any of the firmware resets, then «a downgrade to Catalina» is highly unlikely to perform any better.
(Incidentally, there have been a few cases of hardware failures that caused both Big Sur and Catalina to have power drain and other issues. Hopefully, you aren’t another case.)