Hi DJDesrosiers,
Thanks for coming to Apple Support Communities for help today with your Mac and Touch ID. It sounds like it doesn't always work for you.
Check out: Use Touch ID on Mac
"Use Touch ID to unlock your Mac, log in, or switch users
To use Touch ID for these tasks, you must have logged in to your Mac already by entering your password.
- Unlock your Mac and some password-protected items: When you wake your Mac from sleep, or open a password-protected item, just place your finger on Touch ID when asked.
- Log in from the login window: Click your name in the login window, then place your finger on Touch ID.
- Only user accounts that have passwords can be unlocked with Touch ID. Share-only users and guest accounts cannot use Touch ID.
- Switch users: Click the fast user switching menu
in the menu bar, choose a different user, then place your finger on Touch ID.
To use Touch ID to switch to another user, you need to have set up fast user switching, and the user you switch to must have logged in to the Mac already by entering a password."
And also:
"If you have problems with Touch ID
- If Touch ID doesn’t recognize your fingerprint: Make sure your finger is clean and dry, then try again. Moisture, lotions, cuts, or dry skin can affect fingerprint recognition.
- If you still have to enter your password: For security, you need to enter your password when you start your Mac. Sometimes you need to enter your password to continue using Touch ID. For example, users must re-enter their password every 48 hours and after five incorrect fingerprint attempts."
Have a fantastic day!