Recommended Surface Scan App for Hardisks and SSDs for MacOS Big Sur?

Hello Mac friends.


Any recommended surface scan app for hardisks that runs on MacOS Big Sur (APFS format)? Freeware is preferred. How about for NVME SSD (freeware preferred as well)?


Thank you.

God bless.

iMac 27″, macOS 11.5

Posted on Aug 16, 2021 2:35 AM

Reply
9 replies

Aug 16, 2021 3:27 PM in response to Alvin777

Hello thanks for the replies.


I meant, on Windows there's a surface scan feature on an app called 'Aoemei Partition Assistant'.


Surface scan mean, it scans the hardisk physically for bad sectors and marks that as unuseable, so it's never written with data. If there's an equivalent of that on MacOS Big Sur, that is compatible with the APFS format, that you can recommend (preferably freeware or trial but the full features are all unlocked), that'd be most welcome.


How about a similart app for SSDs that check that each cell of the SSD is not bad (preferably freeware or trial too), that's recommended?


Thank you.

Aug 16, 2021 8:48 PM in response to Alvin777

Surface scan mean, it scans the hardisk physically for bad sectors and marks that as unuseable, so it's never written with data.

The hard drive controller takes care of that on its own. You don't need to do it. The OS doesn't write to sectors. The OS tells the drive controller to write data to the drive. The drive controller writes the data. If it discovers a bad sector in the process, it maps it out to one of the reserves.

Aug 17, 2021 6:57 AM in response to Alvin777

Alvin777 wrote:
...How about a similart app for SSDs that check that each cell of the SSD is not bad (preferably freeware or trial too), that's recommended?

Thank you.

SSD firmware automatically marks bad sectors and removes them from access and then replaces them with the drive's spare blocks and verifying any writes from pretty extensive cache. So bad blocks are impossible to write. So they cannot be written to. Unlike HDD, the sector map is dynamically changing because of the firmware's mapping is constantly updating because of of the internal functions as garbage collection which can move things all around then a new sector map is created. Also, such an app would create excessive wear to the SSD as in their process they need to generate write, which SSD blocks only have a limited number of.


Also, even modern HDDs have vastly improved their functionality in this regard.


Surface scans are a thing of the 80's when at the time mass storage technology simply was not as sophisticated as today and are really of not much use any more as drive firmware has become sophisticated enough in its error checking that it is simply not needed.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Recommended Surface Scan App for Hardisks and SSDs for MacOS Big Sur?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.