I agree--there are still a lot of unknowns. Some people are claiming all the units look "warm" while others, such as yourself, have found variations... Regardless, if you've got a yellow-biased screen, I'm not sure that's a bad thing for the reasons I mentioned. If you're into photography, this may well be a better calibration.
As for the visual lack of contrast, I suspect the reason for this is that a percentage black (say 90% black) would appears as pure black on the old iPhone (with its 2.2 gamma), but will will look truer (and therefore grayer) when the gamma is raised to 1.8. In theory, this means the old phone was displaying <100% black values as 100% black, while the new phone requires a tonal value closer to 100% to appear dark black.
As for the yellow tint, the baseline "warmth" of the screen has probably been increased--as you correctly point out, we've gotten way to used to cheap "overly cool" lcd screens, and a properly calibrated one often looks too warm at first...
I could be totally wrong about this--we might find out these are just a batch of "off" screens--but regardless, they seem to perform better than the old ones in terms of absolute color balance and color clarity. Or maybe I'm just trying to make myself feel better. I do, after all, prefer the experience of using the older screen... đ