Hi,
you would need to take a picture of your phone and someone's else that you thought was better than yours, for us to see.....
BUT in saying that I would think that lots of people have either (yellow tinted or blue tinted or whatever) and are very happy with them as long as they don't have
1. OCD [Obsessive-compulsive disorder] (like me and others)
2. Vision up close problems (usually starts to happen to people in the 40's) (like me and others) [blue is better on the eyes when reading with these small devices]
3. Hardware problem that I and apple thought I had with the 1st one.
I also had a couple other problems with mine one being on the phone, the phone app locked up on me, dropped my call and I had to end the phone app to get back into it, and it rebooted on me randomly also, when my 4 did none of this (well maybe not the random reboot but if it did I can't remember).
I called apple and between phone lock up, random reboot, yellow tinted, and a very soft home button they said for me to go back to the store and get it replaced as apple could not guaranty a new on if they sent me one so I called my best buy stores around me to find another one to swap it out for a new one.
Now the new phone for me
1. No more yellow tint when comparing side by side
2. Much easer on the eyes when reading
3. I had some type of batter draining issue with my yellow tinted screen (1st 4s) this new 4s battery is great, like the 4 was.
4. Home button fells better (but still not like the 4 but satisfactory)
5. For the phone and lock up problem time will tell if it happens it did take 9 days to show up on the first one that could have just been a glitch but I did reboot the device in the morning before it showed up so time will tell.
Best luck to all