Okay, so I received my replacement today. When I first turned it on there was a blue-green tinge to the left-top of the screen. It was slight, but there. As I have been using it messing with the brightness comparing between phones, the tinge has subsided some. My original phone's display didn't look great right out of the box either but has improved moderately. I don't know why this is, but my advice for anyone wanting to compare is to use it a few days. You can't compare right out of the box, because the uniformity and color accuracy seem to change from when they are first turned on.
I'm going to use the replacement a few days and see how I feel. I think the whites are whiter with the replacement than the original and whatever defects it has may be less noticeable. The replacement is also definitely somewhat brighter. Wife confirmed this. I'll report back in a few days.
For my really expensive retina macbook pro15" I went through many many replacement to get a perfect screen, which I now have. However, I don't think I'm going to do that with the iPhone. Too much stress. In the future, I'm always going to order multiple of whatever product I am buying from apple, choose the best screen, and then return the rest. That would be easier than this hassle of getting replacements.