Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

iPhone 8/ 8 plus home button cracked

I have been using my iPhone 8 for a little over 6 weeks. Last night I plugged in my phone to charge and walked away for about an hour. When I came back the phone had turned off and I observed a hairline crack running across the home button. The phone was not dropped or even touched during this time. It honestly just spontaneously cracked. I know that the iPhone 7 had a similar issue but I was not able to find anyone that had experiences a similar issue with the iPhone 8.

I called Apple care and they advised that it would be anywhere from 99-600 dollars to have the home button replaced. Has anyone had a similar issue with their iPhone 8 or 8 plus? Thank you.

Posted on Nov 9, 2017 1:29 PM

Reply
Question marked as Best reply

Posted on May 28, 2018 8:04 PM

Here you go, I have changed some details but you get the jist. Also I cant share the email address as it pertains to my particular Apple case ID and mine has been closed. You will need to reply to the email you receive from the Apple rep.I hope this helps your case and I hope this gets more traction to get the wider issue looked at.

Hi,
Firstly, thank you for your great customer service and support yesterday and making an
exception to fix my iPhone 8 + screen due to the home button cracking itself.
However, this is not the end of the issue and I will list them below;


  • I went to Oobe in Wellington NZ yesterday and the guy advised based on the notes that Apple will fix the screen (home button included) free of charge however any other damage resulting from this issue they will not cover.
  • He asked me to wipe my phone but back it up first at home – I tried to update it then back it up but the phone, either hardware or software, has corrupted terribly and now it has been restored to factory with several issues to me personally.
    1. I lost ALL my data as it would not update and self-restored to factory settings – I had a lot of baby photos from January (we had a newborn on Jan 3rd) and I hadn’t backed up my phone as we moved into my in-laws house while we
      build our house so my computer is in storage making it difficult to do my once a month back up to my PC. I also had some personal notes not backed up anywhere which is also painful. I never thought my 7 month old phone would break so quickly.
    2. The phone after restoring still will not boot up to the hello screen or anything else so I used an existing back up to restore to the phone and that did not work so it keeps looping through apple logo, bar loading and then black screen which suggest it could be something more than just the screen itself, it could be a hardware or software issue that you advised would not be covered as only
      the screen replacement is covered by Apple.
  • I have logged a claim with my insurance company as I think this will not be resolved as easily as I think and this will cost me $200 excess as well as a penalty on my non-claims bonus. This is pending and I haven’t undertaken this course of action yet but the claim is lodged.
  • I did some further research on this issue and found many threads that replicate exactly what happened to me and my device. Reading the comments reiterated to me that I did not drop or bang my phone but this happened on its own via some faulty hardware or just pure bad design. Below are the threads I have looked at and most come from the Apple community forums on the Apple website. I will
    restate; I did not drop the phone, I did not bump it against anything, I did not handle it roughly prior to the damage and I never have. I had used it with no issues, then 5 mins later charged it, then not long after I pulled out the lightning cable and placed into my pocket but had not checked the phone so it could have been damaged by then. I went to the bathroom and kitchen and after 5 mins I went to my desk pulled it out of my pocket and saw the damage. It sits in a Otterbox symmetry case with a screen protector on it – it is cared for as if it is one of my children and cost me $1449 NZD which I still have not fully paid for yet.
  • Here are the threads I mentioned and they all have a common theme – they were charging it and came back to see damage. Could it be that the charging is causing this issue:
    1. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8153835 - my phone looks exactly as the picture in this thread
    2. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8269914
    3. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8308437
    4. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8250804 - this is exactly my issue
    5. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8069340 - subject line refers to iPhone 7 but some comments mention iPhone 8
    6. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/7742979 - also iphone 7 related but they use the same/similar hardware for the home
      button
    7. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8093709
    8. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8046417
There are many more of these re iPhone 7 on Apple’s website and from other websites but I think you get the point.
Im very frustrated that I can easily see a common theme here but Apple doesn’t – I have wasted time, energy and money on this issue and Apple hasn’t accepted liability they have only just made an “exception” for me where I see a bigger issue.
I am tempted to go to my commerce commission, Fair Go (NZ TV show that deals with consumers being ripped off) and our media outlets to vent my frustration and make this known to the wider community.
My main concern is that this may happen to other people and they go through the same process as me and get frustrated and potentially lose all their data (like I did which is causing me a massive headache and my new-borns pictures from his birth cannot be recovered ).
This shouldn’t happen and the response from Apple’s reps is unacceptable.
I will await your response before proceeding with what action I will take.
Please reply as quickly as you can as I need to make a decision soon.
Thanks.
255 replies

May 29, 2018 7:53 PM in response to jbzlez

Guys!!! I have some really good news. So I’ve been following this thread since it happened to me April 20. Since then, I’ve gone to Apple twice, been turned away blaming me for physical damage, shed a few years and contemplated throwing this phone at a brick wall a few times lmao. But yesterday, I gave it one last shot before I attempted to have to pay a bulls**t amount of $250 to replace the screen on my 8 plus (3 months old at that). I decided to chat with an Apple advisor. I explained the whole situation, sent this thread, sent her pics of the home button and everything. Now her exact words after chatting and asking me questions like “was the phone warm when you found it in that condition” ect, she said after doing some digging apparently this issue is “apparent and recognized”. So yes this issue is recognized by Apple so guys do not give up. Be persistent. Chat with an advisor and explain the situation, she set me up with a repair, I now have a case created with all of her evidence toward my case. I’m going into Apple tomorrow to get this fixed, for FREE, once and for all! She said if they give me trouble to refer to my case number and ask for a manager. I will let you guys know what happens tomorrow!!! Keep being persistent and do not pay these people to fix this phone when it’s their fault. Good luck guys

May 31, 2018 9:06 PM in response to Emcampb2

Wow this amazes me! I went to the Apple store and was told it would be $170 fix, I refused. Then the manger came over and said she’d give me a discount so the total would be $100... I refuse to pay another cent for a defective device!! This iPhone 8Plus is already well over $800, and they want me to pay to fix a problem I didn’t cause? I can’t believe how all the pics show almost the same exact cracking!User uploaded file

Sep 20, 2018 8:42 PM in response to Emcampb2

So same thing happened to my phone today around 530pm. I had my phone in my hand as I was walking to the yoga studio. Then I felt my

thumb got hot and I looked at my phone and it was all of

a sudden on the Apple screen frozen and the home button is cracked !! I was so confused as I did not drop my phone. I use Spotify and iTunes for my class and I couldn’t bc my phone is on freeze mode. Luckily another teacher was able to let me use her phone so I can teach my class. This very upsetting and stressful. I don’t have money to spend on repair. I’ve only had this phone for a month and a half . I will be taking my phone to Apple store tomorrow and I hope that they fix it!User uploaded file

Nov 12, 2018 5:22 PM in response to Emcampb2

’m not happy. Brought a new iPhone which was sent directly from Apple. Was using it fine for like a couple of weeks when I charged it came back and the home screen button was cracked and I hadn’t touched it. This enabled the touch screen to work so I wasn’t able to get on any of my apps. I then did some digging onto apple Communities here and realised that a lot of people were experiencing the same problem. I went onto twitter to express my disappointment and Apple support asked me to DM (Direct message) them I did that and after speaking to them they said it was best to go in store. Today I went to the Istore and i spoke to a manager and he said he’d need permision from Apple support to go ahead with a free repair and would do it if he could. He said he has seen this issue before and it was best to contact support again. After waiting ages for Apple support to finally reply they told me I needed to go in store again. I find it absolute rediculous that I am being passed from one to another. Apple are just ignoring the problem completely. All they care about is making a profit and not about delivering good customer service. I am not happy with my treatment And I’m comsidering not using Apple again. Apple is clearly responsibe for this issue why ignore me?


User uploaded file

Feb 6, 2018 7:06 AM in response to Lowes.47

You won't necessarily receive a "new phone" as warranty replacements don't work that way. You might, or you might receive a refurbished phone, those are the terms of the warranty.


Regardless, once again, if you are experiencing this issue, be sure to take it in to your local Apple Store/servicer for analysis.


Apple will investigate the issue if they start to see a "pattern."


Also be sure to report your issue to Apple here:


Product Feedback - Apple

Mar 20, 2018 7:05 PM in response to alexandrafromoberlin

Remember we are fellow Apple users here, not Apple Support.


The best way to contact Apple directly for general issues like this is here:


Product Feedback - Apple


Apple certainly tracks issues, and if enough people with AppleCare+ are seeing this they will certainly note a spike in repairs.


(I only state AppleCare+ as people without may choose other venues to pursue a repair.)

Mar 26, 2018 5:02 PM in response to istudio76

I agree with Chris; you were lucky they agreed to pay for the repair. My daughter's phone was barely two months old. She isn't rough on gear (hers was an upgrade from a 5c that was still working fine) but they basically insisted we were lying about the fact that the phone did this all by itself....

PLEASE go to Product Feedback - Apple

and outline what happened to you there. We all need to do that...

And thanks for posting!

Apr 3, 2018 5:18 PM in response to deggie

Feedback reported...


https://www.apple.com/feedback/


Suspected Design or Mfg Defect on iphone 8 Plus


I recommend an investigation for the iphone 8 Plus home button cracking issue. As of today, it may still be early in it's life, but many consumers like me are having their home buttons mysteriously cracking and malfunctioning without abuse, dropping, or other unusual activities.


Apple Stores have not acknowledged this as a defect for warranty claims yet, but I recommend a prudent investigation.


My 3 month device was just repaired for $169+tax, for what I consider should have been a warranty, defective item.


What makes this area too weak to last a few months of vibration and interaction?


Thank you for getting this to the right people to read forums, read repair logs, investigate and correct the issue, and refund consumers who had to pay.

Dec 24, 2017 2:08 PM in response to s2bbthur

Same thing just happened to my phone. All of a sudden the home Buttom is not working and I didn’t drop it or do anything to my phone. It’s like it exploded from the inside. I took it to the store and they want $169 plus tax to fix it. My phone is just over 30 days old. I didn’t pay almost 1k to have it go bad like this. Plus if it goes bad for no reason that means it will continue to happen so I really wish Apple would look into it and fix it.

iPhone 8/ 8 plus home button cracked

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.