Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

iPhone 8/ 8 plus home button cracked

I have been using my iPhone 8 for a little over 6 weeks. Last night I plugged in my phone to charge and walked away for about an hour. When I came back the phone had turned off and I observed a hairline crack running across the home button. The phone was not dropped or even touched during this time. It honestly just spontaneously cracked. I know that the iPhone 7 had a similar issue but I was not able to find anyone that had experiences a similar issue with the iPhone 8.

I called Apple care and they advised that it would be anywhere from 99-600 dollars to have the home button replaced. Has anyone had a similar issue with their iPhone 8 or 8 plus? Thank you.

Posted on Nov 9, 2017 1:29 PM

Reply
Question marked as Best reply

Posted on May 28, 2018 8:04 PM

Here you go, I have changed some details but you get the jist. Also I cant share the email address as it pertains to my particular Apple case ID and mine has been closed. You will need to reply to the email you receive from the Apple rep.I hope this helps your case and I hope this gets more traction to get the wider issue looked at.

Hi,
Firstly, thank you for your great customer service and support yesterday and making an
exception to fix my iPhone 8 + screen due to the home button cracking itself.
However, this is not the end of the issue and I will list them below;


  • I went to Oobe in Wellington NZ yesterday and the guy advised based on the notes that Apple will fix the screen (home button included) free of charge however any other damage resulting from this issue they will not cover.
  • He asked me to wipe my phone but back it up first at home – I tried to update it then back it up but the phone, either hardware or software, has corrupted terribly and now it has been restored to factory with several issues to me personally.
    1. I lost ALL my data as it would not update and self-restored to factory settings – I had a lot of baby photos from January (we had a newborn on Jan 3rd) and I hadn’t backed up my phone as we moved into my in-laws house while we
      build our house so my computer is in storage making it difficult to do my once a month back up to my PC. I also had some personal notes not backed up anywhere which is also painful. I never thought my 7 month old phone would break so quickly.
    2. The phone after restoring still will not boot up to the hello screen or anything else so I used an existing back up to restore to the phone and that did not work so it keeps looping through apple logo, bar loading and then black screen which suggest it could be something more than just the screen itself, it could be a hardware or software issue that you advised would not be covered as only
      the screen replacement is covered by Apple.
  • I have logged a claim with my insurance company as I think this will not be resolved as easily as I think and this will cost me $200 excess as well as a penalty on my non-claims bonus. This is pending and I haven’t undertaken this course of action yet but the claim is lodged.
  • I did some further research on this issue and found many threads that replicate exactly what happened to me and my device. Reading the comments reiterated to me that I did not drop or bang my phone but this happened on its own via some faulty hardware or just pure bad design. Below are the threads I have looked at and most come from the Apple community forums on the Apple website. I will
    restate; I did not drop the phone, I did not bump it against anything, I did not handle it roughly prior to the damage and I never have. I had used it with no issues, then 5 mins later charged it, then not long after I pulled out the lightning cable and placed into my pocket but had not checked the phone so it could have been damaged by then. I went to the bathroom and kitchen and after 5 mins I went to my desk pulled it out of my pocket and saw the damage. It sits in a Otterbox symmetry case with a screen protector on it – it is cared for as if it is one of my children and cost me $1449 NZD which I still have not fully paid for yet.
  • Here are the threads I mentioned and they all have a common theme – they were charging it and came back to see damage. Could it be that the charging is causing this issue:
    1. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8153835 - my phone looks exactly as the picture in this thread
    2. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8269914
    3. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8308437
    4. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8250804 - this is exactly my issue
    5. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8069340 - subject line refers to iPhone 7 but some comments mention iPhone 8
    6. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/7742979 - also iphone 7 related but they use the same/similar hardware for the home
      button
    7. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8093709
    8. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8046417
There are many more of these re iPhone 7 on Apple’s website and from other websites but I think you get the point.
Im very frustrated that I can easily see a common theme here but Apple doesn’t – I have wasted time, energy and money on this issue and Apple hasn’t accepted liability they have only just made an “exception” for me where I see a bigger issue.
I am tempted to go to my commerce commission, Fair Go (NZ TV show that deals with consumers being ripped off) and our media outlets to vent my frustration and make this known to the wider community.
My main concern is that this may happen to other people and they go through the same process as me and get frustrated and potentially lose all their data (like I did which is causing me a massive headache and my new-borns pictures from his birth cannot be recovered ).
This shouldn’t happen and the response from Apple’s reps is unacceptable.
I will await your response before proceeding with what action I will take.
Please reply as quickly as you can as I need to make a decision soon.
Thanks.
255 replies

Jan 12, 2018 7:30 AM in response to Csound1

What makes you so sure it's nonsense in all your wisdom? Or do you mean nonsense in regards to replacing the whole phone which obviously isn't required.

In addition to all the other reported cracked home buttons on iPhone 7&8's. My girlfriends iPhone 8 which is 2 weeks old has just had the same issue. Her phone was on charge and when she went back to it she found the home button was cracked. The phone came straight out the box and into a Tech 21 Evo case and full screen glass protector when purchased and has never been dropped or had any sort of "rough" treatment. There is something obviously not right here and we will be contacting Apple about it tomorrow. Sadly though from other people's experiences we are not expecting any help in regards to a warranty repair in relation to this. We will see.

Jan 12, 2018 7:39 AM in response to Emcampb2

I am happy to report that Apple did fix the problem but had to replace my phone. However, it was a huge headache. At first, I was quoted unreasoneable amounts of money to repair it. I spoke to many reps who found this unusual. The problem with the 7 and 8 plus is that they have a sensor under the home button so the home button can’t simply be resurfaced. I agreed to send in my phone (as I do not live by an apple store.) It was a headache at the ups office which even required Apple to contact them. However, once it was sent back it was determined that they would replace it vs repair it. I was sent a new phone in 2 business days.

Jan 12, 2018 5:35 PM in response to Csound1

Mate you seem to be taking this very personally and would think your paying for the repairs yourself. You're not the owner of apple are you lol 😂. Have I done extensive research into this NO. I just done a google search for cracked home button on iPhone 8 and came across a number of posts for the iPhone 7 & 8 that have had this happen to them for no apparent reason. Then I found the posts in the apple forums as per below screen shot which show a number of people agreeing in the "me too" tab. It may not be thousands or millions of people but enough that obviously there is an unexplained problem with the button cracking.

Jan 13, 2018 7:41 AM in response to Csound1

My quest is over 😃 Took the phone into Apple today and they replaced it with a brand new phone. They did say they hadn't heard of it before and I did point out the number of posts in their support pages and other threads on the net for the same issue. They first offered a repair or a replacement refurbished phone which we was not pleased with considering our phone is only 2 weeks old. Anyway, they eventually said they would replace it with a brand new one which we happily accepted. Good result I reckon, but quite honestly wouldn't have been happy with anything less. Just hope it doesn't happen again………

Jan 15, 2018 7:23 AM in response to Impreziv

lucky u .. i was sitting w/family andmy phone was in my leg and when look at it. . home button was crack and and the iphone stuck in the apple logo and when i try to complain to phone company that i bougth from it .. they say isnt the company problem ... 😭.. and there are no replacement button on my country .. what to do .. plz help ..😭🙈

Jan 18, 2018 5:52 PM in response to Emcampb2

Canadian iPhone 8 Plus owner here...same exact issue happened for me today and I’m raging. I just purchased my iphone 8 Plus through my carrier last week, and I’m traveling in the US on business currently, stuck with a phone that spontaneously developed a crack on the home button and is stuck in boot mode. I’m really, really annoyed. This is a huge problem given that I’m away from home on business and desperately need my phone.


The moment I opened my phone at my carrier’s store, it was put into an Otterbox and a glass screeen protector was installed. I have treated it very carefully (obviously since it’s so very new, I’m being even more careful with it than usual). I put my phone on the counter in the bathroom while I had a shower. When I got out of the shower, I noticed that it was in constant boot mode with just the white apple screen showing, and it was only when I went to hard reset it that I noticed a crack on the home button. I am 1000% sure the crack was not there when I put it on the counter before the shower. I even said to my coworker “How the ****?? This thing just spontaneously developed a crack! How can this possibly be?” Low and behold I went online and found this thread on the Apple forums!


Apple better make this right or I will be a former customer! I have been a customer for YEARS, and have nothing but Apple all through our house...iPhones, iPads, Apple TV etc. This is the first time I have encountered a manufacturer’s defect with an Apple product, and after spending CDN$1000 less than 10 days ago, I am expecting a brand new replacement unit. Unfortunately, even if Apple makes this right, it won’t help my current predicament being out of the country on business with a broken phone! VERY UNHAPPY CUSTOMER.

Jan 20, 2018 1:58 AM in response to IdrisSeabright

The same thing has happened to my wife’s brand new iPhone 8 Plus 256Gb after less than 2 day’s use. I bought it 2 days before Christmas, she opened the box on Christmas Day and the very next day the home button spontaneously cracked and is in an endless boot loop.


I have no Apple Stores nearby so no one can fix or replace this. I just hope I can get the Apple Store in Singapore to fix or repair this for free when I travel there soon otherwise that’s $1,500 down the drain. So disappointed.

Jan 20, 2018 2:12 AM in response to Emcampb2

Hello Emcampb2! As it turns out, the Home button crack itself would be requiring a display replacement since it is part of the display fixture, since it is made of sapphire and is on a separate level than the display, it would require some sort of impact in order to crack or have any fractures. I would recommend stopping by a Genius Bar and a technician can get you a good $169 for a display replacement (as long as theres no extra damage, of course)

Jan 20, 2018 4:10 AM in response to CsecTech

This is false. I am absolutely certain there was no force or impact applied to my home button. It literally developed a crack spontaneously. I was using the phone right up until I stepped in to a 10 minute shower. Came out of the shower and the phone was cycling through boot mode and had a cracked home button. No other damage anywhere, no one else anywhere near the phone while I showered as it was on the bathroom counter in the locked bathroom With me. The crack on the home button is such that I would DEFINITELY have noticed it under my thumb as it is quite sharp, and it was NOT there prior to my shower.

Jan 21, 2018 4:10 PM in response to lbwl

An update - I took my phone to Apple today and spent 2 hours with the Genius Bar technician while he ran diagnostics and tried to get my phone out of constant boot loop (unsuccessfully) and the technician advised that the logic board is toast. Since the phone is a brick, they were unable to retrieve my data subsequent to the last backup (which was on Jan 13) so I lost a number of pictures taken while I was in Florida, which is just an added annoyance. They did replace the phone, however they would not give me a brand new “retail” unit. After 2 hours, I just wanted to leave the store with a phone that works and I didn’t have the mental bandwidth to argue. I showed the technician this thread and made sure that he logged my boot loop issue complete with cracked home button to make sure they log it as related issues. Even he conceded the home button is remarkably difficult to damage and damage to it in the absence of other damage to the phone was highly unusual.


Good luck to everyone else dealing with this most unpleasant situation!

Jan 22, 2018 3:48 AM in response to Emcampb2

I have an absolutely the same problem! I've bought an Iphone 8 a couple of months ago and just a few days before the New Year my home button stopped responding and showed a virtual one on the screen. Later that day I've noticed a small crack on the home button. There was no damage to the phone and when I took it to the local service they've admitted that it's in perfect shape, not a scratch. And today they've called me and stated, that they REFUSE to change it because this crack is considered a MECHANICAL problem (o my, no, really?!)!!!! Claiming I must pay 420 euros to get it changed for the defect I DIDN'T CAUSE! This was my first attempt of switching to an iphone from Samsung Galaxy and I got this crap! I will never buy another apple iphone or ipad device. And considering what is happening to the new MBP series.. well!!!!

iPhone 8/ 8 plus home button cracked

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.