Merged Voicemails after IOS 17 Update

***** HERE IS THE FIX: Go to SETTINGS, choose APPLE ID, then choose ICLOUD, then choose SHOW ALL, then DESELECT the PHONE toggle… (we turn everything off as we don’t use iCloud for anything) … made three test voicemail calls just to check and it worked *****

No, this is not a solution. I own two phones with the same ID - one for business, another for private. I do not intend to have different IDs for two phones of mine. So far, it has worked perfectly, now Apple has messed up. If it is a bug, please let us know when this bug is fixed.

That’s not a solution!! Not possible to have IDs for all family members. Has worked for the past 15 years! This has something to do with IOS 17!!

I have the same issue, i have a work phone and a personal phone both have different apple id since years past because of the annoying syncing of iphones and it worked well until this ios17 came in it all of a sudden merged my voicemails and sometimes calls. When i have them both sode by side it makes this wierd syncing.

its very annoying i have ti manually delete each voicemails thats not for work or my personal.

Is there any fix to this???

After spending four hours chatting and then talking to ATT with no solution, I called my local ATT Store and chatted with a worker there. After spending some time thinking about it, she suggested both phones turn off Live Voicemail (Under Phone in Settings). So far, I believe this did the trick. If it was that easy, I wasted five hours today online, and chatting, and calling. I really hope this is the solution.

Four different Apple supervisors have told me has nothing to do with Apple ID. I have shared an Apple ID for the past 15 years and have never had this issue.

No luck with any of the proposed solutions, and yes we understand that Apple's solution is separate IDs. Apple's "solution" to a problem which has not existed for many years, however, is obviously not satisfactory for a large number of customers.

I have read so many of these forums, trying to get help to fix this problem. To only see many being scolded to stop sharing Apple ID’s. You are the one and only person that I have found to offer a possible solution. My husband and I both did this. So far, so good. Thank you dear, for sharing something that is potentially helpful.

Apple did change the rules. In the early days there was no family sharing and they gave no instruction on what do. Later they came out with family sharing said how to make that work. But it was too late. We had lots of apps on our phone. Then iCloud changed everything again and not for the better. Software should adapt to my lifestyle; I shouldn’t have to adapt to it.

I am not incorrect. If you use the same Apple ID on two iPhones, Apple sees them as the same in terms of data, which includes phone call logs and voicemail. You can disagree with me all you wish, but it's a fact and whether you use 5 different carriers on 5 different phones all using the same Apple ID, the call logs and voicemails will be shared among all five devices.

I am not defending Apple, nor commenting on whether how they are doing this is right or wrong. It's how Apple chose to do it. I get you may not like this. So feel free to share your thoughts with Apple here --> Feedback - iPhone - Apple

Not one person here has anything to do with Apple, nor how Apple chose to design the user interface on any Apple products.

Same issue! Apple denies the issue has anything to do with them! All last week I spoke with five different Apple supervisors as well as went to two different stores and they all blamed the carrier. I’ve called AT&T and spoke with five different supervisors and they can’t figure out the issue, blaming Apple for the problem. I even went to the AT&T store for four hours and they couldn’t accomplish anything as well. This is absolutely ridiculous, and definitely a privacy concern. Apple has told me has nothing to do with Apple ID because the voicemail is set to each specific phone.

I use the same Apple ID for my work device as I do my personal device. Phone numbers are different. I am now getting mixed voicemails due to the iOS 17 update. There is no need for me to have different Apple IDs for my work device. This is a great feature and should be able to be toggled off or routed similarly to that of iMessage abilities. As a developer, this would be the appropriate approach to this type of function.

Thank you to Rich Feitelberg for your response on a possible solution. So many people taking time to scold those who share an Appleid. When we set up our phones for our kids we all shared the same applied. They did not have family sharing then. Also it made it really easy to monitor the kids and usage. Now they are older but we are all so intertwined with our contacts, music, notes, calendar, find my iPhone, etc.... that there is a huge concern of starting over or not being able to truly share/sync. This worked flawlessly before. No reason to not continue. And yes, I already sent feedback directly to Apple.

Thanks, but I'm not worried if my wife gets my voicemails and vice versa. Sharing one Apple ID is so much easier for the sharing of contacts. Some day we may have to change but for now, we will roll with one.