karyn29 wrote:
...
Your inference that different Apple devices with different operating systems shouldn’t work the same way is a logical fallacy that entirely negates one of the prime motivators for brand loyalty; namely, the ease of use created by continuity across products.
It is nice when things work the same, and I encourage you to send feedback to Apple with your arguments, as the volunteers here cannot change anything
Feedback - Watch - Apple
But while the same is nice, it is not always practical because the devices are a different form factor. A Mac has a keyboard and pointing device for input, where as an iPhone has up/down volume, power, and mute buttons, plus a good size touch screen.
An iPad has similar controls to an iPhone, with an even larger touch screen and the option to use a pencil for input.
An Apple Watch has 2 buttons for the Series and SE lines, and an extra button on the Ultra. The touch screen is rather small, and limited in the things you can cram onto the screen, and in some cases the screen is too small for easy tapping on a button.
How the devices are used is different, so sometimes what is a useful way to interact with one device is a waste on another.
So given the limited number of input options on the Apple Watch, there is only so far you can keep the UI features identical to the iPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Watch, etc...
The people developing the Apple Watch UI are trying to maximize the things they think are most important to the user based on all the feedback they get from the above feedback link, the Apple Support calls, the Genius Bar visits, and developer bug reports.
And they also make decisions on new features they want the Apple Watch to perform in the future, that may not fit into the current UI model, and are looking for a way to get these new features into the product and accessed in as easy a way as possible.
NOTE: I am not saying I like all the UI changes. If nothing else, it is a pain, as a forum volunteer, to keep repeating myself on how to access the features users think they have lost. (Thank goodness for Keyboard -> Text Replacement)
I am just telling you that developers have to live within constraints of the hardware they are working with. I am sure that a college grad did not decided to change everything on a whim. I'm sure there were meetings about these changes, with mock-ups and lots of management decision makers in the mix. I am sure, because, while I have never worked for Apple, I have worked for several Fortune 500 companies as a software developer, and meetings are a pain in the ....
Again, put your arguments together, and send them to Apple
Feedback - Watch - Apple