Dannymac22 wrote: Maybe someone could just agree with what I am seeing.
It looks to me like everyone understands exactly what you are seeing. You have a picture like this:
You don't like that tower to be at such a funny angle, so you straighten it and get this
With the tower nice and straight (and my wife leaning....)
But you wanted this:
And it seems to me that everyone told you that Photos doesn't do that-- Photos always makes rectangular pictures. This is not unusual for popular image editors. In fact, I don't remember anyone in this discussion group ever before mentioning that they needed this, so it's not likely to be something Apple would add to Photos.
That's why léonie thoughtfully suggested using GraphicConverter ($40) which is what I used to make the above image of the famous leaning wife of Pisa.
By the way, there is no "expansion" going on. As Yer_Man explained, in Photos, the remaining picture fills the screen, just like any other pictures does. One of the main advantages to straightening and/or cropping a picture is that the main subject better fills the screen.
I hope this helps you see what we see...
