Below is a copy of the explanation that Will616 posted. It is the best explanation I've seen of what is going on.
------------------------------------------------ Copy of Posting ------------------------------------------
I have the same issue. I have identified at least 4 other
separate threads on the apple forums as well as numerous threads on other forums.
I will attempt to précis them here and also provide links so you can read
through my sources yourselves. Note there is, as always, a significant
amount of duff information, guessing and questionable fact obscuring the useful
evidence.
- 1. This issue only appears to be affecting people with email
accounts set up for pop/smtp.
- 2. Following upgrade to iOS 9 / iOS 9.01 and possibly the 9.1
beta as well, email content is removed from the iOS device resulting in a
sudden decrease in the storage required for the mail app.
- 3. Emails that may have been present on the device for many
months and accessed multiple times in both the inbox and sent items will be
randomly replaced with the basic placeholder information (similar to a IMAP
case prior to download) but with the body and attachments replaced by the
statement: This message has not been downloaded from the server.
- 4. Deleting the account and setting it up again from scratch
does not resolve the issue and will result in the loss of all the email
placeholders - further increasing your loss of knowledge so you can't even work
out what you've lost (tried it with one of my 4 accounts - won't be doing any
more of them). I forwarded a lost message that was held on my iMac
archive back to the newly set up pop/smtp account and it appeared and was
accessible for about 12 hours before reverting to 'This message has not....
- 5. Switching the account to IMAP if you go for a delete and
re-setup will also result in the loss of all the email placeholders but will
'probably' solve the problem (within the limitations of IMAP) for future
emails.
- 6. This affects all iOS devices - iPads (all gens on iOS 9)
iPhones (all gens on iOS 9). It is not affecting the same email accounts
on our OS X machines (an iMac)
- 7. This issue affects you irrespective of you country, internet
provider or email provider - the discriminator is the use of pop/smtp. It
is disappointing that a number of apple customers have paid for support and
been palmed off with this as a possible cause.
- 8. pop/smtp is not legacy or backward compared to imap it is
just different. We use pop/smtp for 3 reasons: we don't want emails left
on the server where a questionably secure environment could be compromised; our
family want the ability to all download the same email to multiple devices
without affecting each others ability to do so; we want one master device (the
main iMac) to be the deleting device that holds the archive of all emails
(right now we are very pleased we have this as all the iOS devices are scorched
earth right now).
- 9. Some emails appear unaffected - I cannot identify any rhyme
or reason to this. Old, new, addressee, - there doesn't seem to be a
pattern. Can't say for certain but it seems that more are being affected as
time goes on. If you are affected and you have the only copy of an email
currently and you are going to need it again.....get it somewhere else ASAP!!!
- 10. This thread and forum is just for sharing knowledge between
users. If this has affected you then you need to fill in the apple
feedback page with your confirmed symptoms and the impact if you want anything
to be done. Follow this link and do it now or apple pop users will remain
without a fix! I recommend do one for each type of iOS device you have
affected and the mail app itself.
http://www.apple.com/feedback/
Here are the other apple forum threads related to this issue -
maybe someone else is familiar with a clever way to link them all up - please
do so if you know how:
https://discussions.apple.com/thread/7226924
https://discussions.apple.com/thread/7221489
https://discussions.apple.com/thread/7226501