Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Cracked screen MacBook Pro with Touch Bar

Devastated to say that my relatively new MacBook Pro with Touch Bar has a cracked display/LCD at the bottom on the screen. I'm not particularly rough with my MacBook and presumably this occurred due to closing the screen with something between the keys and the screen. I recall the moment the crack appeared, so this would have been a dust speck. Although I have AppleCare, the cost of repair is $680, since this is "accidental damage" and "out of warranty"


The new machine seems much more fragile than my older MacBook Pro's which are still going strong 5 years in!


Have others had problems with a fragile displays?

MacBook Pro (15-inch, Late 2016), macOS Sierra (10.12.5), null

Posted on Jun 26, 2017 12:01 PM

Reply
Question marked as Best reply

Posted on Mar 11, 2020 9:49 AM

I came upon this thread (https://discussions.apple.com/thread/7995345?page=1) after I too experienced crushing and cracking damage of the logo baffle from something which dropped, unseen, into the “jaws” of the screen-hinging area of my new, 13-inch, 2018 MacBook Air. 


Clearly, this is a defect in “materials and workmanship” which subject the MBs to easy accidental damage and, therefore should be covered by the warranty.


  • The material in question is the fragile, glass-like logo baffle which can easily crack and shatter given enough local pressure. Materials with such characteristics should never be used in areas subject to vice-like pressures or, for that matter, normal pressures encountered in screen cleaning. Future designs should mitigate such vice-like mechanics in cover/screen hinging.


  • The workmanship in question is the design of the screen/body hinging, where the space between the screen (and logo baffle ) diminishes as the screen/cover is closed, trapping and crushing anything which has fallen, unnoticed, into the dark, yawning gap, damaging the logo baffle and, possibly, the display screen, too.


As with defective airbags, the manufacturer, i.e., Apple, should be responsible for:


  • Issuing a product warning to all owners of relevant MacBook models regarding this accidental damage vulnerability and measures to take to mitigate such damage*;
  • Developing and offering free replacement of the defective part, one which would not be easily subjected to such damage; and
  • Repairing, at no charge, damaged logo baffles and display screens which have already occurred.


___

*I believe most of us would never have experienced damage if Apple had alerted us to the possibilities of such. We would then have attended to and avoided debris which might easily or otherwise, fall between the cracks with such costly consequences.

810 replies

Jul 1, 2020 10:56 AM in response to DPJ

It's Apple's fault because through normal use, surface stress across the screen compromises it; usually near the hinges. The design on the touch bar units is different than the previous models, and pinpoint cracks, like the ones all over this thread would take a very precise, nearly surgical strike, to the screen. I'm sorry, but the notion nearly 2000 people who've reported "I have this problem, too" didn't all close their screens on a paper clip, or USB-C device as Apple geniuses are trained to tell you.


Apple is not infallible; iphone antennas sometimes don't work, batteries prematurely fail, and new-and-improved keyboards aren't. It's convenient to say of course YOU damaged the screen. But mine sits closed, plugged into an external monitor, and it starts itself up and shuts itself down through the power manager-- And on one of the few occasions I've opened it (don't travel much since COVID-19 lockdown), there's a crack, that's somehow my fault. No. It's. Not.


So "DPJ" your assertion this problem can only happen through misuse--and Apple bears no responsibility to either correct the problem, or at least warn its customers these these screens are/may be very susceptible to damage through normal use-- is wrong. These aren't crap Windows laptops, they're top of the line MacBooks, and at nearly $3K a pop, Apple should own up to an inherent flaw in their screen design.


Oct 20, 2020 4:00 AM in response to drtimothy

i have a 2019 MacBook Pro . I have noticed a bump in the bottom bezel just to the right of the ‘ MacBook Pro’ branding . Have given it to apple service today and am awaiting this reply . According apple online support it was claimed to a manufacturing defect but when I took it to the service center they say I may be charged .

Dec 6, 2020 3:16 PM in response to drtimothy

Looked for such a thread 2 years ago, but didn't see it. Repetitive story, but happened to me as well.


3 weeks after I'd gotten it, a crack suddenly appeared on the bottom plastic part of the screen.


I was dumbfounded as nothing I had done could explain why it had happened - as it had just laid on my desk and been opened and closed normally... At least since, then, there's only been that crack. It hasn't impacted anything else, just that when you such a stylish looking device, it just doesn't look good....


Feb 2, 2021 12:50 AM in response to NicoletteBG

Hi. You said that you put electrical tape over the cracked baffle. Does it work to prevent more crack on the baffle? I’m afraid if i put electrical tape, the cracked baffle will spread and it will affects my laptop’s LCD. And do you experience something bad with the LCD? Or is it fine, just the crack? Thank you.



I accidentally crack my laptop’s baffle when I’m about to close it.

May 27, 2021 7:06 AM in response to drtimothy

have the same issue, 3 months old MacBook pro 16'' never dropped or got hit, I carefully used it for 3 months when I discovered an internal crack in the top of the screen near the camera, all screen went black, Apple lab demands 1000$ to replace the screen. this is my third MacBook Pro and it's far behind the first two, the materials are low quality and unfortunately, the Apple products are not as good as they used to be. have the same screen issue with a brand new iPad as well, cracked screed without any physical damage.

Sadly moving to win... don't see any future for a company that does not care about its customers...


Dec 13, 2017 9:33 PM in response to drtimothy

Hello


This happened to my machine as well. Some lines have appeared on the screen, and it seems that there was a shock (i cannot see a trace of it... but they say they can).


My computer is barely 5 weeks old. I will have to pay a hefty amount for the repair as well. I know how i treated my machine, and this should have never happened. If a really minor shock cause the problem (minor in the sense that i can't remember it) , then the machine is not worth its price.


I spent some very frustrating time at the AppleStore, and with AppleCare. Was notably told "this never happens" "screens do not break on their own ". I am somehow relived to see here similar experiences.


AppleStore and AppleCare were unhelpful.


I am utterly disappointed.

Cracked screen MacBook Pro with Touch Bar

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.