Aperture in macOS High Sierra...

Hi,


This is just feedback back to the Aperture community.


I updated my MacBook Air (2014) to the latest macOS 10.13, all seems good with Aperture. Adjustments look fine, loupe, importing, exporting.

If I come across any issues, I'll post back.


I do have a Mac Pro (2010 SSD w/ Apple RAID) to update. That'll wait until the WACOM drivers are released end of Oct.


I'm still waiting on a good alternative to Aperture...

Currently the ACD See app (although well spec'd for Windows) has very good potential. Currently there is a beta for Mac users.

I will still check in on Capture One / Lightroom (?7) on occasion.


ATM Aperture is still working (for now) 😎

Posted on Sep 26, 2017 5:48 AM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Sep 27, 2017 1:39 PM

léonie is correct about your Mac… it will eventually die and/or become useless. This is how I decided to deal with the issue:


My “working” Aperture computer is a 2009 Mac Pro which reached end-of-life 1-2 years ago (Apple stopped making replacement parts). I run it on Yosemite to avoid the few minor problems that Aperture has with more recent OS’s. Last year, I bought a used 2012 Mac Pro that I use for all my other work — it is now running High Sierra. I use “Carbon Copy Cloner” to copy an updated version of my Aperture library to the new computer every few days (CCC is fantastic!). I don’t do any edits on the new computer, but my Aperture library is available for reference, plus this copy acts as another backup. If needed, I can install Yosemite on the newer computer and use it as a “back up” computer for Aperture if/when my other computer dies.


I am slowly migrating my photos to Lightroom on the new computer, but want to complete a huge project of scanning/editing ~50,000 old family photos (from 1885 to 2003) in Aperture before I use Lightroom exclusively. This project will take ~2-3 more years to finish, so hopefully one, or both computers will still be operational. After that, I will simply use Aperture as an archive and use Lightroom for all my future (digital camera) work.


Finally, I also have been exporting a copy of my final edited jpegs to the “Photos” app on the newer computer. Photos — or some future version of the software — will probably be around as long as Apple exists. I periodically give my family members an updated copy of the Photos library. The Aperture and/or Lightroom libraries will simply die after I stop using them. No one will want to deal with those programs, but the Photos app is used by all my family members. This should help assure that the photos out-live me!


The 2012 Mac will probably be at “end-of-life” in the next year, or so. The 2009 Mac is easily the longest I have ever used a computer. However, I can’t imagine using either computer 5 years from now. You’ll have to face the final demise of Aperture at some point! You don’t want all your photos to be lost because you didn’t migrate to a “living” program!

130 replies

Nov 17, 2017 6:11 AM in response to Gary O'Kane

Hi!

I just tried to install Aperture 3 (trial) that I still had, but I could not install it. I loved A3 before they discontinued with it, and had to move to Lightroom. But now when Adobe killed all non subscriptions, I am abandoning Adobe totally. I like C1P, but it cannot handle a cataloge with alot of photos...


So I really want to use A3 again. Anyone who knows how to install from scratch on Sierra/High Sierra?

Nov 25, 2017 7:39 PM in response to Gary O'Kane

I had loaded all my photos in Aperture & set up new Projects. However, at some point I opened Photos & now all my pics and Projects are in the Photos System library & I can't get them back into Aperture. I tried copying the System Library & renaming to Aperture, but that didn't work. Apparently, only Photos can access the System Library. Aperture was working fine up to that point. Any ideas?

Nov 26, 2017 3:58 AM in response to marti h

The migration from Aperture to Photos created a separate Photos Library. It renames the filename extension of your Aperture library from ".aplibrary" to ".migratedaplibrary". Select your Aperture Library in the Finder and change the filename extension back to ".aplibrary", then double click the renamed Aperture Library to open it again in Aperture. Or did you delete the Aperture Library?

Jan 5, 2018 9:15 AM in response to Allan Eckert

Allan Eckert wrote:


Sure but every little bit helps.

That may be true.

I had plans when we heard that Apple had erred in its evaluation of the importance of the Mac Pro to remind them of their misunderstanding the value and importance of Aperture and software like Bento.

Decided Tim was too involved with selling phones and social values to be interested in past Apple ventures.


"Besides I thought it was better for him to post there where it is possible to something rather then here where

we can't."


True again! I've often wondered why Apple supports these discussion, but doesn't seem to read/listen to what's said here.

Jan 9, 2018 8:47 PM in response to David Strait

I wish you luck with the huge scan project. We are on the same track. I'm undertaking a similar effort. I had a 2008 Mac Pro and replaced it with a 2010 Mac Pro which just hit end-of-life. I can install High Sierra, but that may be the last.


I recently completed the scan part but my job was much smaller, perhaps 5000 scans. It took a couple of years but I took breaks. While the scanning is complete I created digital negatives for all the slides and film negatives and they all still need to be organized and "developed". May take another year!

Feb 3, 2018 9:07 PM in response to Gary O'Kane

Hey Gary,


im exactly in the same situation. My only concern is what happens if do to future updates of OS at one point in time Aperture will stop working at all...I would be deeply frustrated (to put it mildly) if I then would not be able to migrate the library content to some place else and lose everything, cannot even imagine that. I guess I'll export all the photos onto an external drive just to be sure


Would really like sb from Apple to comment on here to get some more certainty!


Thanks.


Pat

Feb 4, 2018 4:57 AM in response to Appeltjehehe

The problem there is you're going from one non-destructive database app to another one: essentially they are the same kind of app, so, to send back a non-destructive version C1 has to send back a tiff. If you want non destructive processing you should really stick to one or the other. Settle for sending back a jpeg and you'll have the sizes you want and still have the original in Photos.


Ideally you would use one or the other. Using both makes little sense.

Feb 4, 2018 3:27 PM in response to Appeltjehehe

I was only checking out the possibilities with editing apps


I think you're confusing editors - like Photoshop - and database driven non-destructive Processors like Capture One. Editor edit the photo - the add and subtract bits. Processors don't do that. They are, effectively, digital darkrooms. They never change the photo, simply record your decisions.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Aperture in macOS High Sierra...

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.